Demo

Senior Recruitment Consultant

Oliver James
York, NY Full Time
POSTED ON 12/18/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 1/16/2026

This position is for an experienced Recruitment Consultant working in our New York City office, focusing on P&C Insurance Claims permanent recruitment. You'll be responsible for Talent Acquisition of top talent within the insurance claims space, as well as Business Development of Oliver James's existing clients.


Working at OJ:

At Oliver James people are our strength, they are our competitive edge and the key to our success and the service we provide.


When you join OJ, you enter an environment where your career progression is taken seriously. From day one, our global People and Performance team will work with you to build your confidence and knowledge through a tailored training program, and this remains the case at every stage of your career.


We provide you with the platform to perform to the best of your ability and continuously develop. You have the authority and accountability to be responsible for the speed and success of your own career progression and development through a transparent promotion pathway, providing you with a clear route to progress.


Every team at OJ is made of individuals with unique strengths, so we provide an inclusive work culture that is collaborative and committed to a collective vision. You will work with some of the most talent professionals and will be supported by investment in the world’s most innovative tools and OJ’s agile working environment.


We work hard, are ambitious, but most importantly, we celebrate success and love what we do! If you have the drive to be the best at what you do, you can expect high levels of trust and support in return. Wherever you want your career to go, OJ will provide you with the platform to take your career to the next level.


About the role

As Senior Consultant your responsibilities will be:

  • Business Development of new and existing clients, leveraging Oliver James's excellent brand reputation to pull job requisitions in insurance and financial services spaces, where teams place actuaries, accountants, brokers, claims analysts, and more.
  • You'll spend your days going on client meetings, making client calls, and providing the highest level of service to hiring managers.
  • You'll be headhunting both passive and active top talent within the claims space to work with Oliver James on exclusive opportunities.
  • As an experienced recruitment hire, you'll be supporting and collaborating with other divisions and team members.


About you

  • 3 years of Staffing Agency recruitment experience
  • Business Development/Client facing experience as a Full Desk/360 Recruiter within financial or professional services
  • You're interested in leading by example, and building others to work as one and win as one
  • You're flexible and adaptable, with the goal of strengthening relationships and devoting interest to secure understanding
  • You thrive in a targets-focused environment, creating goals to enable autonomy and growing vision to build inspiration.


What we offer

  • Transparent promotion pathway at every level
  • Excellent and competitive benefits
  • Tailored training at every level - personal coaching tailored to you, not just standard classroom training
  • Festive close-down between December 24th and Jan 1st holiday allowance of 15 days and a separate bank of sick/personal days
  • Monthly OJ get togethers
  • Quarterly and Annual Company Events such as our summer and holiday parties, and quarterly lunch club incentives
  • Extended lunch break for gym-goers or personal appointments from 12:30 - 2 PM
  • An energized office environment with a skyline view balcony at Rockefeller Center, with weekly local perks and events
  • This role has a base salary range of $70,000 up to $90,000 depending on experience.
  • This role has immediate access to an uncapped commission structure in addition to the base salary


Introduction to OJ New York from Stewart Cherry, Senior Vice President, New York

Welcome to OJ New York!


Our New York office has experienced exponential growth since opening in 2016 and is home to some of the highest performers in the industry; people who are incredibly talented and driven entrepreneurs and have been able to develop their careers alongside the growth of OJ.


It’s our aspiration to be one of the leading recruitment companies in the U.S. both to work for and with. We are set to double in size in the next 2-3 years and are looking for highly driven and ambitious people who will take charge of their career, grab the opportunities that arise, and make their market on the future of OJ New York.


As a business we constantly strive to improve and deliver excellence, and we expect you to do the same. You are surrounded by the best of the industry and everyone works towards a common goal -achieve success, deliver excellence, and have a lot of fun whilst doing it.


OJ New York has an engaging and collaborative environment. From day one and throughout your career, you are given a transparent and tailored promotion pathway, providing you with a clear route to progress, as well as the opportunity to take your career and earning potential to the next level.


If you have the drive to learn, work hard, and are ambitious, our global People and Performance team will help (and challenge) you to perform to the best of your ability every day.


There has never been a more exciting time to join our high performing New York team!

Salary : $80,000 - $90,000

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Senior Recruitment Consultant?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Senior Recruitment Consultant career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$95,396 - $131,741
Income Estimation: 
$131,357 - $193,022
Income Estimation: 
$95,368 - $117,770
Income Estimation: 
$95,697 - $123,113
Income Estimation: 
$100,711 - $126,643
Income Estimation: 
$128,610 - $169,671
Income Estimation: 
$131,357 - $193,022
Income Estimation: 
$162,444 - $208,834
Income Estimation: 
$195,801 - $254,734
Income Estimation: 
$95,697 - $123,113
Income Estimation: 
$131,357 - $193,022
Income Estimation: 
$120,763 - $148,970
Income Estimation: 
$117,414 - $153,024
Income Estimation: 
$162,444 - $208,834
Income Estimation: 
$131,357 - $193,022
Income Estimation: 
$195,801 - $254,734
Income Estimation: 
$122,946 - $157,956
Income Estimation: 
$131,357 - $193,022
Income Estimation: 
$162,444 - $208,834
Income Estimation: 
$195,801 - $254,734
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Oliver James

  • Oliver James Quincy, MA
  • The Agency Controller oversees all financial operations of the organization, ensuring accuracy, transparency, and adherence to accounting standards. This r... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Oliver James Chicago, IL
  • Our client, a leading investment management firm, is seeking a Tax Senior Manager to oversee tax operations for mutual funds and ETFs. This is a FULLY REMO... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Oliver James Orlando, FL
  • Oliver James is working with a specialty insurer that is looking to hire a Claims Manager (TPA Oversight) for their Casualty team. In this standalone senio... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Oliver James Tampa, FL
  • Position Overview The Compliance Manager, Commercial Lines will take charge of the development and management of new commercial insurance products. This ro... more
  • 14 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Senior Recruitment Consultant jobs in the York, NY area that may be a better fit.

  • unfiltered rec York, NY
  • Are you a high-performing recruiter ready for your next challenge? We’re partnering with a number leading recruitment firms in New York City , looking for ... more
  • 19 Days Ago

  • Joss Search York, NY
  • Senior Recruitment Consultant Contract and Temporary Hires - Private Equity New York - In office Monday to Thursday (Work from home on Fridays) $70,000-$90... more
  • 7 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!