Demo

WSI Auto Claims Supervisor

Arrowhead Programs
Garden, NY Full Time
POSTED ON 1/10/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 2/9/2026
Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers.

Arrowhead Programs Company is seeking a WSI Auto Claims Supervisor to join our growing team in Garden City, NY!

This WSI Auto Claims Supervisor will be responsible for the daily supervision of the automobile unit. This position requires supervising claims from all 50 states.

How You Will Contribute

  • Supervise, direct, assist and support a team of auto adjusters
  • Assure the prompt investigation, evaluation, and disposition of all first- and third-party automobile property damage claims, and automobile property damage liability claims as well as automobile bodily injury, Med Pay, No-Fault, UM/UIM claims
  • Assure the prompt reserving of all claims managed within the automobile unit
  • Assure an effective working relationship with our clients, brokers, and attorneys
  • Assure an effective working relationship with all disciplines
  • Assure prompt re-insurance reporting
  • Manage the subrogation process
  • Conduct timely performance reviews and compliance audits of adjuster’s files
  • Assist in the selection, training, and development of all employees within the unit
  • Accept temporary assignments away from the office to assist large claim events
  • Prepare written documents for company and carrier reporting
  • Participate in and prepare responses for Arbitration

Licenses And Certifications

  • Valid driver’s license/Real ID

Skills & Experience To Be Successful

  • Bachelor’s degree or life experience
  • At least eight years of experience in handling commercial automobile claims
  • Experience with catastrophic claim handling
  • Home State General Adjusters License and ability to obtain adjusters license in States that require licensing
  • Good telephone demeanor
  • Proficient use of a PC

Pay Range

$95,000 - $105,000 Annual

The pay range provided above is made in good faith and based on our lowest and highest annual salary or hourly rate paid for the role and takes into account years of experience required, geography, and/or budget for the role.

Teammate Benefits & Total Well-Being

We go beyond standard benefits, focusing on the total well-being of our teammates, including:

  • Health Benefits: Medical/Rx, Dental, Vision, Life Insurance, Disability Insurance
  • Financial Benefits: ESPP; 401k; Student Loan Assistance; Tuition Reimbursement
  • Mental Health & Wellness: Free Mental Health & Enhanced Advocacy Services
  • Beyond Benefits: Paid Time Off, Holidays, Preferred Partner Discounts and more.

Not reflective of all benefits. Enrollment waiting periods or eligibility criteria may apply to certain benefits. Benefit details and offerings may vary for subsidiary entities or in specific geographic locations.

The Power To Be Yourself

As an Equal Opportunity Employer, we are committed to fostering an inclusive environment comprised of people from all backgrounds, with a variety of experiences and perspectives, guided by our Diversity, Inclusion & Belonging (DIB) motto, “The Power to Be Yourself”.

Salary : $95,000 - $105,000

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a WSI Auto Claims Supervisor?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the WSI Auto Claims Supervisor career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$36,789 - $51,333
Income Estimation: 
$39,377 - $54,570
Income Estimation: 
$69,116 - $84,792
Income Estimation: 
$95,639 - $124,292
Income Estimation: 
$123,613 - $165,638
Income Estimation: 
$97,158 - $125,490
Income Estimation: 
$123,613 - $165,638
Income Estimation: 
$142,348 - $187,535
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
Income Estimation: 
$97,158 - $125,490
Income Estimation: 
$142,348 - $187,535
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Arrowhead Programs

  • Arrowhead Programs Overland Park, KS
  • Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers. Arrowhead Autom... more
  • 5 Days Ago

  • Arrowhead Programs Fort Wayne, IN
  • Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers. Brown & Brown i... more
  • 5 Days Ago

  • Arrowhead Programs Overland Park, KS
  • Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers. Arrowhead Autom... more
  • 8 Days Ago

  • Arrowhead Programs San Diego, CA
  • Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers. The Staff Accou... more
  • 8 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other WSI Auto Claims Supervisor jobs in the Garden, NY area that may be a better fit.

  • Progressive Hyde Park, NY
  • Progressive is dedicated to helping employees move forward and live fully in their careers. Your journey has already begun. Apply today and take the first ... more
  • 1 Month Ago

  • Plymouth Rock Assurance and Careers Uniondale, NY
  • The Senior Auto Property Damage Claims Representative is responsible for managing Auto Property Damage claims within our “Auto PD Claim Unit.” This role de... more
  • 18 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!