Demo

Benefits Account Manager

PRESTIGE EMPLOYEE ADMINISTRATORS and Careers
Melville, NY Full Time
POSTED ON 3/8/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/7/2026
Reports To: Director of Benefits

Company Overview


For more than 25 years, we have provided cost effective employee benefits and HR services with transparent pricing and personalized, high quality support. We take pride in building long-term relationships and strong partnerships with our clients, going the extra mile to deliver exceptional service. As a data driven and results focused organization, we are committed to solving HR challenges of any size. By managing HR complexities, we empower our clients to focus on operating—and growing—their businesses while we support them with expert HR solutions.‑effective employee benefits and HR services with transparent pricing and personalized, high‑quality support. We take pride in building long‑term relationships and strong partnerships with our clients, going the extra mile to deliver exceptional service. As a data‑driven and results‑focused organization, we are committed to solving HR challenges of any size. By managing HR complexities, we empower our clients to focus on operating—and growing—their businesses while we support them with expert HR solutions.

Position Description


The Benefits Account Manager supports and manages relationships with a portfolio of high‑end clients and brokers, delivering elevated service tailored to complex and premium client needs. This individual serves as a knowledgeable and trusted advisor, ensuring the seamless coordination of benefit administration, proactive issue prevention, and prompt resolution. Acting as the primary operational point of contact for clients, worksite employees, brokers, and insurance vendors, the Account Manager maintains strong, service‑driven relationships and ensures an exceptional client experience. This role anticipates client needs, supports sophisticated benefit discussions, and contributes to continuous improvement—enhancing the overall value delivered to high‑end accounts.

Roles & Responsibilities

Client, Broker & Relationship Management

  • Provide consultative guidance to assigned brokers and clients, focusing on day‑to‑day benefits administration and identifying opportunities to enhance service and client satisfaction.
  • Manage client expectations through proactive communication, timely follow‑up, and consistent delivery of high‑quality support.
  • Support and guide Benefits Specialists in daily tasks and service delivery, offering coaching on operational workflows without full strategic oversight.
  • Build and maintain effective working relationships with benefit vendors and carriers to ensure smooth coordination of services.
  • Participate in vendor meetings to address service needs and assist in resolving operational issues.

Presentations & Communications

  • Conduct presentations and employee meetings to explain available benefit options and help clients understand plan features.
  • Communicate benefit and renewal updates to clients and employees through in‑person or virtual meetings (e.g., Teams, RingCentral).
  • Prepare clear and accurate employee‑facing benefit materials based on client specifications.
  • Manage and distribute benefit-related communication materials for worksites and employees, ensuring accuracy and timely updates.

Renewal & Enrollment Management

  • Coordinate and manage the renewal process, ensuring smooth communication, accurate documentation, and timely delivery of client materials.
  • Participate in medical underwriting conversations with internal partners to support renewal preparation.
  • Provide guidance and troubleshooting support for benefit enrollment portals.
  • Review and audit employee benefit enrollments and elections to ensure accuracy.
  • Support the setup and administration of non‑Prestige benefit plans, coordinating with external vendors as needed.

Issue Resolution

Partner with benefit vendors, carriers, and internal teams to investigate and resolve:
  • Claim‑related issues
  • Eligibility discrepancies
  • Billing errors
  • Coverage concerns
  • COBRA‑related matters
Ensure timely and accurate resolution of employee and client concerns, escalating complex issues as appropriate.

Cross-Functional Collaboration

  • Collaborate with internal client‑facing teams to support integrated service delivery and maintain consistent communication.
  • Analyze issues and participate in collaborative problem‑solving to ensure a smooth and unified client experience.
  • Manage benefit-related communication materials for worksites and employees, ensuring content is accurate, up‑to‑date, and delivered consistently.

Industry Knowledge & Compliance

  • Attend relevant conferences, webinars, and networking events to maintain current knowledge of benefits programs, federal and state regulations, and PEO industry trends.
  • Stay informed of insurance coverage developments, market changes, and product offerings.
  • Provide guidance on ACA compliance and related requirements.
  • Oversee setup and ongoing administration of non-Prestige benefit plans.
  • Conduct audits with the Operations team.
  • Process life events and status changes promptly and accurately.
  • Participate in regular vendor meetings to support issue resolution and service delivery.

Required Skills

  • Strong interpersonal and relationship-management skills.
  • Ability to manage multiple renewals simultaneously.
  • Excellent written, oral, and presentation communication skills.
  • Solid understanding of employee group benefits, including COBRA.
  • Strong analytical and problem solving abilities.‑solving abilities.
  • Sales mindset with the ability to identify and upsell additional product offerings.
  • Ability to work independently and collaboratively within a team.
  • Strong computer proficiency and adaptability to new systems.
  • Ability to perform well in a high pressure environment.‑pressure environment.
  • Knowledge of HRIS systems; Salesforce and Prism preferred.

Required Experience & Qualifications

  • Minimum of five years of client-facing and/or sales experience in group employee benefits.
  • A thorough understanding of group health plans with the ability to analyze data and prepare recommendations.
  • Experience in a consultative, strategic role with demonstrated relationship-building skills.
  • Active Health and Life License required.
  • PEO experience is required.
Must be able to work hybrid: 3 days in the office, 2 days work from home.
Salary range is between 85 - 90K based on experience

QVFgFTtBgZ

Salary : $85,000 - $90,000

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Benefits Account Manager?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Benefits Account Manager career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$65,036 - $83,221
Income Estimation: 
$80,418 - $105,051
Income Estimation: 
$89,823 - $111,340
Income Estimation: 
$117,681 - $153,066
Income Estimation: 
$167,784 - $219,716
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Benefits Account Manager jobs in the Melville, NY area that may be a better fit.

  • EKA Planning Services, Inc Huntington, NY
  • We are a well-established insurance brokerage & consulting firm in Huntington NY. This an IN PERSON office position. Our primary focus is on group benefits... more
  • 11 Days Ago

  • SR Staffing Melville, NY
  • About the Company My client is a premier insurance, risk management, and financial services firm headquartered in Melville, NY. The company serves more tha... more
  • 2 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!