Subrogation Unit Manager

Davies Talent Solutions is partnering with a leading insurance organization seeking a Property Claims Subrogation Unit Manager to lead and oversee a high‑performing, multi‑state subrogation operation. This role provides strategic direction, technical leadership, and operational oversight to maximize recovery outcomes across property claims.

This is an excellent opportunity for an experienced subrogation leader or senior property claims professional who excels in recovery strategy, team leadership, and complex loss evaluation.

Key Details

• Onsite in their Orlando or Sarasota office
• Full‑Time | Monday–Friday
• Competitive compensation, commensurate with experience

What You’ll Do

• Provide oversight and strategic direction for all property claims subrogation activities, including identification, investigation, evaluation, negotiation, arbitration, and litigation
• Supervise subrogation staff and/or vendors, including TPAs, collection agencies, arbitration forums, and legal partners
• Develop, update, and enforce subrogation policies, procedures, and best practices
• Grant authority and provide technical guidance on liability evaluation, recovery strategy, and settlement negotiations
• Ensure compliance with internal policies, subrogation best practices, and all applicable statutory and regulatory requirements
• Monitor and report key subrogation metrics, including recovery ratios, cycle times, aging, arbitration outcomes, and litigation results
• Manage quality control and auditing of subrogation files to ensure timely pursuit and maximized recovery potential
• Coordinate catastrophe‑related subrogation efforts, including large‑loss and multi‑party recoveries
• Collaborate cross‑functionally with property claims units, underwriting, legal, finance, reinsurance, and external partners
• Serve as Corporate Representative in mediations, arbitrations, depositions, or court proceedings as required

Required Experience

• Active Florida or Texas Adjuster License (additional state licenses a plus)
• 7–10 years of progressive experience in property claims and/or subrogation management
• Strong operational‑level property and casualty claim handling experience
• Demonstrated expertise in the subrogation lifecycle, including liability analysis, comparative negligence, product liability, contract transfer, and arbitration
• Proven ability to evaluate large and complex recovery opportunities
• Experience managing litigation, arbitration, and recovery negotiations
• Prior field claim and management experience within an insurance carrier or large TPA environment
• Strong analytical, decision‑making, written, and verbal communication skills
• Valid driver’s license with a satisfactory motor vehicle record

Preferred Experience

• Multi‑state experience, particularly FL, TX, and CA
• Experience coordinating reinsurance recoveries and reporting
• AIC and/or CPCU designation
• Florida 620 and/or Texas Adjuster License