Demo

Casualty Claims Supervisor

Badger Mutual Insurance Company
Milwaukee, WI Full Time
POSTED ON 9/27/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 3/25/2026

($95,000-$110,000 annual salary - based on experience)


Historic company. Startup mentality.


As a Casualty Claims Supervisor at Badger Mutual Insurance, you have the opportunity to join a relationship-based company whose foundation was built upon compassion, protection, and fostering the education and success of our employees. Your responsibilities will include the prompt investigation, settlement and payment of claims, and the training, development and performance of staff. 


What Will You Do?


»     Supervise, mentor and support a team of claims adjusters

»     Assign daily claims for prompt investigation, equitable settlement, and timely payment

»     Review and approve claims which exceed adjuster’s authority level

»     Negotiate complex, high exposure claims, authorize payments within authority level and establish reserves as needed

»     Consult with legal counsel on litigated claims and present evidence at legal proceedings

»     Review and approve claimant complaint responses

»     Report and document potential high-risk and reinsurance claims

»     Provide guidance on complex claims and act as an escalation point for resolution

»     Develop and implement best practices to improve claims efficiency

»     Collaborate with underwriters, agents and other departments to ensure consistency and service excellence

»     Provide training and development, including leading case discussions at meetings

»     Maintain a positive working relationship with policyholders, agents, vendors and attorneys


Job Requirements


»     Bachelor’s degree in related field or equivalent education and work experience

»     Minimum of 10 years of claims experience

»     Prior supervisory experience preferred

»     Excellent verbal and written communication skills

»     Strong analytical, problem solving and critical thinking skills

»     Ability to manage workload independently and effectively

»     A confident decision maker with negotiation skills

»     Good judgement, a great work ethic and highly self-motivated

»     Proficiency in Microsoft Suite software


Please apply online at: https://www.badgermutual.com/careers/

Salary : $95,000 - $110,000

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Casualty Claims Supervisor?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Casualty Claims Supervisor career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$63,693 - $82,116
Income Estimation: 
$78,860 - $101,439
Income Estimation: 
$73,591 - $100,276
Income Estimation: 
$92,577 - $120,619
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$188,132 - $272,100
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Badger Mutual Insurance Company

Badger Mutual Insurance Company
Hired Organization Address Milwaukee, WI Full Time
($24.25-29.09/hour - based on experience) Historic company. Startup mentality. As a Client Services Specialist at Badger...

Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Casualty Claims Supervisor jobs in the Milwaukee, WI area that may be a better fit.

Daily Claims Adjuster – Milwaukee, WI Region

CENCO CLAIMS LLC, Milwaukee, WI

Property & Casualty Account Manager

Bridge Specialty Group, Milwaukee, WI

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!