Demo

Claims Team Manager, Auto Bodily Injury

Zurich North America
Overland Park, KS Full Time
POSTED ON 10/29/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 11/27/2026
At Zurich North America Claims we acknowledge that work life-balance and flexibility are a priority when it comes to choosing your next career move. Designed with our employees' needs in mind, the ZNA Claims hybrid work model emphasizes flexibility, allowing claims employees to conduct individual work in their preferred location, while facilitating in-person connections and collaborative activities when meaningful and valuable. While the model provides a high level of flexibility and autonomy, occasional circumstances requiring in-office attendance should be expected. The candidate selected for this opportunity should be able to report into [one of] the following North American Claims office[s]: Dallas, Texas; Atlanta, Georgia; Schaumburg, Illinois; Overland Park, Kansas; Omaha, Nebraska; or Gold River (Sacramento), California.

Responsibilities:

  • Lead, coach and develop a team of Auto Bodily Injury Claims Handlers, setting clear performance expectations and fostering accountability, engagement, inclusion and professional growth.
  • Coordinate teamwork activities and resource allocation to support effective inventory management, service delivery and operational performance.
  • Provide technical and operational oversight of low- to high-exposure, non-litigated auto bodily injury claims, including liability, causation, damages, coverage, reserve and settlement.
  • Drive superior claim results by providing direction and technical guidance and by tracking and reporting key quality, service, productivity and financial metrics.
  • Ensure claims are investigated, evaluated, reserved, documented and resolved timely and accurately in accordance with delegated authority; Zurich Claims Best Practices, customer instructions and legal and regulatory requirements.
  • Review and approve claim strategies, evaluations, reserves and settlement recommendations within delegated authority, escalating significant exposures, emerging issues and matters outside authority as appropriate.
  • Conduct regular file reviews, quality reviews and performance discussions to strengthen investigation, documentation, evaluation, negotiation and resolution practices.
  • Use claim, service and productivity data to monitor results, identify trends and implement action plans addressing inventory, cycle time, reserve accuracy, quality, leakage, productivity and customer outcomes.
  • Achieve customer satisfaction targets by building and maintaining strong relationships with internal colleagues, customers and brokers; providing proactive communication; responding to escalations; and resolving quality or service concerns.
  • Partner across Claims, Legal, SIU, Subrogation, Vendor Management, Underwriting, Risk Engineering and other functions to address claim-specific and portfolio-level issues.
  • Manage expenses by monitoring file assignments, staffing and other costs to ensure efficient resource use.
  • Ensure compliance with state licensing requirements, unfair claims practices regulations, internal controls, audit standards and all other applicable legal and regulatory obligations.
  • Lead change initiatives and support talent, process and technology improvements that advance Zurich's claim strategy and operating model.

Basic Qualifications:

  • Juris Doctor and 5 or more years of experience in the Claims area OR
  • Bachelors’ Degree and 6 or more years of experience in the Claims area OR
  • High School Diploma or Equivalent and 8 or more years of experience in the Claims area AND
  • Customer service experience
  • Experience with Microsoft Office
  • Experience collaborating across work groups
  • Knowledge of insurance legal statutes and procedures
  • Knowledge of the insurance industry, claims and the insurance legal and regulatory environment
  • Travel 0-20%

Preferred Qualifications:

  • Prior direct people-management experience with demonstrated success setting expectations, coaching performance, developing talent and fostering an inclusive, accountable team environment
  • Experience handling auto bodily injury claims involving liability, causation, damages and coverage
  • Demonstrated judgment in evaluating exposure, setting reserves, establishing claim strategy, exercising settlement authority and escalating material risks
  • Experience managing team performance through operational metrics, file-quality results and action plans addressing inventory, cycle time, reserve accuracy, leakage, productivity and customer outcomes
  • Strong working knowledge of multi-jurisdictional auto liability laws, regulatory requirements, internal controls and claims governance
  • Demonstrated ability to influence across functions and organizational levels, manage escalations and communicate clear recommendations to senior claims leadership
  • Strong customer and broker relationship-management skills, including the ability to balance account expectations with sound claim handling, compliance and financial discipline
  • Excellent communication, negotiation, decision-making and conflict-resolution skills, with the ability to lead through complex or sensitive claims and personnel matters
  • Demonstrated success leading process, technology or organizational change and translating broader claims strategy into executable team priorities

Your pay at Zurich is based on your role, location, skills, and experience. We follow local laws to ensure fair compensation. You may also be eligible for bonuses and merit increases. If your expectations are above the listed range, we still encourage you to apply—your unique background matters to us.

The pay range shown is a national average and may vary by location. The proposed salary range for this position is $100,200.00 - $164,100.00, with short-term incentive bonus eligibility set at 15%.

We offer competitive pay and comprehensive benefits for employees and their families. [Learn more about Total Rewards here.]

Do you know someone who would be perfect for this exciting role? We’re grateful when you recommend Zurich to your network – it shows you trust us and believe Zurich is a great place to work.

In the US, Zurich North America has two separate talent referral programs. To be eligible for a referral bonus and to make sure your referral is considered, it’s important to submit it under the correct program.

**Referring Current Zurich Employees**

Do you know a current Zurich employee who would be a great fit for this role? If so, Click Here to submit their details. Your colleague will get an invitation to apply for the position, and you’ll receive confirmation of your referral within 1-2 working days.

**Referring External Talent through the Refer-a-Friend Program**

We value the networks of our Zurich colleagues and encourage you to share Zurich job opportunities with people you think could be great future colleagues.

  • To learn more about referring friends and family to Zurich, click here.
  • If you have someone in mind, click the "Refer Friend to a Job" button on the job posting to submit your referral.

If you're looking at internal opportunities, make sure to check out the MakeYourMove@Zurich resource. You can find it on Channel Z under the MyGrowth tab.

Zurich in North America does not discriminate based on race, ethnicity, color, religion, national origin, sex, gender expression, gender identity, genetic information, age, disability, protected veteran status, marital status, sexual orientation, pregnancy or other characteristics protected by applicable law. Equal Opportunity Employer disability/vets.

Zurich complies with 18 U.S. Code

  • 1033.

Location(s): AM - Addison, AM - Atlanta, AM - Gold River, AM - Omaha, AM - Overland Park, AM - Schaumburg

Remote Working: Hybrid

Schedule: Full Time

Employment Sponsorship Offered: No

Hiring Manager Name: Drew Nicolls

Recruiter Name: Michael Gettinger

Job Level: 6M

Division: Claims

Internal Referral Bonus: $500.00

External Referral Bonus: $2,500.00

Salary.com Estimation for Claims Team Manager, Auto Bodily Injury in Overland Park, KS
$107,092 to $132,134
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Claims Team Manager, Auto Bodily Injury?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Claims Team Manager, Auto Bodily Injury career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$123,613 - $165,638
Income Estimation: 
$142,348 - $187,535
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
Income Estimation: 
$87,128 - $112,557
Income Estimation: 
$131,676 - $196,560
Income Estimation: 
$176,392 - $248,211
Income Estimation: 
$163,962 - $219,201
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Zurich North America

  • Zurich North America Portland, OR
  • Zurich is seeking a Finance & Insurance Executive to support sales efforts in our Oregon territory. As part of our F&I sales team, this role offers an oppo... more
  • Just Posted

  • Zurich North America Arizona, AZ
  • Due to continued sales success, Zurich is looking for a Regional Income Development Executive to support the sales efforts in our West Division. The ideal ... more
  • Just Posted

  • Zurich North America Colorado, CO
  • Due to continued sales success, Zurich is looking for a Regional Income Development Executive to support the sales efforts in our West Division. The ideal ... more
  • Just Posted

  • Zurich North America Chicago, IL
  • Zurich North America is looking for a Senior Actuarial Consultant to support Accident & Health (A&H) business. This role would be based out of Zurich’s New... more
  • Just Posted


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Claims Team Manager, Auto Bodily Injury jobs in the Overland Park, KS area that may be a better fit.

  • Zurich North America Overland Park, KS
  • At Zurich North America Claims we acknowledge that work life-balance and flexibility are a priority when it comes to choosing your next career move. Design... more
  • 9 Days Ago

  • Progressive Overland Park, KS
  • Progressive is dedicated to helping employees move forward and live fully in their careers. Your journey has already begun. Apply today and take the first ... more
  • 2 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!