Demo

Claims Casualty Manager

Utica First Insurance Company
Oriskany, NY Full Time
POSTED ON 4/13/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/9/2026
Description

Please note, this position is in-person at our Oriskany, NY location.

Job Summary

The Claims Casualty Manager oversees a team of claims adjusters and manages complex claims for a variety of policies, including general liability, homeowners, and business owners’ policies. This role is responsible for managing the claims process from start to finish, ensuring policy interpretation and coverage analysis, setting claim reserves, and working to achieve timely and cost-effective resolutions. They also conduct data analysis to identify trends, provide insights to other departments, and ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

Reports to: Vice President of Claims

Duties And Responsibilities Include (but Not Limited To)

  • Manage the entire claims process, from initial notification to final resolution, while ensuring the team follows best practices.
  • Provide direction and technical expertise to claims adjusters, especially for complex or litigated cases.
  • Analyze and interpret insurance policies to determine coverage, ensuring claims are overseen in accordance with their terms and

conditions.

  • Oversee claim reserves, monitor file allocations, and other expenses to ensure appropriateness.
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with internal colleagues, external customers, brokers, and other relevant parties to

promote quality customer experience.

  • Ensure the claims process complies with all legal, regulatory, and internal control requirements.
  • Lead, motivate, and develop a high-performance team, and promote UFI Culture and values.
  • Set up and conduct adjuster audit to monitor KPI’s and Company procedures.
  • Respond to insurance department complaints.
  • Perform supervisor and clerical reviews.
  • Review and approve coverage disclaimer letters, large loss notices and 11-month reports.
  • Identify and put in place training needs.
  • Assist VP of claims when needed.

Requirements

  • Strong knowledge of the insurance industry, including various lines of liability insurance.
  • Proficiency in policy interpretation, coverage analysis, and claims management software.
  • Excellent communication, negotiation, and leadership skills.
  • Strong analytical and problem-solving abilities.

Education And Experience

  • Bachelor’s degree required, advanced degree preferred.
  • Professional designations such as CPCU, AIC, SCLA, or equivalent strongly preferred.
  • 8 years of progressive claims experience in the Casualty insurance industry
  • Significant leadership experience managing large, multi-line claims operations.
  • Deep expertise in claims handling, litigation management, reserving practices, and regulatory compliance.

Physical Requirements

This position requires the ability to sit for extended periods while working at a computer in an office environment. The role involves frequent use of a headset, keyboard, mouse, and other standard office equipment. Occasional movement within the office may be required, such as walking to meetings or accessing shared equipment.

Please note, this position is in-person at our Oriskany, NY location.

Pay Range

The actual amount to be offered to the successful candidate will be generally within the posted range but could differ dependent on the key aspects of each case which may include education, skills, experiences, location etc. as determined throughout the selection process.

Compensation details: 100000-160000 Yearly Salary

PI8533b9e16573-25448-39625239

Salary.com Estimation for Claims Casualty Manager in Oriskany, NY
$145,358 to $194,473
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Claims Casualty Manager?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Claims Casualty Manager career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$133,026 - $172,136
Income Estimation: 
$173,898 - $215,349
Income Estimation: 
$175,869 - $224,608
Income Estimation: 
$226,328 - $346,983
Income Estimation: 
$181,348 - $253,947
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Utica First Insurance Company

  • Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY
  • Oriskany, NY Description Utica First Insurance Job Description and Standard of Performance POSITION DESCRIPTION Customer Care Associate Job Summary Custome... more
  • 10 Days Ago

  • Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY
  • Description Utica First Insurance Position Description Job Description and Standard of Performance Staff Accountant Job Summary The Staff Accountant suppor... more
  • 1 Day Ago

  • Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY
  • Description Utica First Insurance Position Description Job Description and Standard of Performance Vice President, Product Management Job Summary The Vice ... more
  • 4 Days Ago

  • Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY
  • Oriskany, NY Description Utica First Insurance Job Description and Standard of Performance POSITION DESCRIPTION Quality Assurance Analyst Job Summary The Q... more
  • 5 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Claims Casualty Manager jobs in the Oriskany, NY area that may be a better fit.

  • Hancock Claims Consultants Technicians Syracuse, NY
  • Hancock Claims Consultants specialize in Ladder Assist and Property Inspection Services, collaborating directly with numerous insurance agencies for effici... more
  • 8 Days Ago

  • NYCM Insurance Edmeston, NY
  • The Casualty Supervisor will coach, mentor, give general oversight and guidance to the casualty team and examiners. They will collaborate with casualty man... more
  • 16 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!