Subrogation Counsel First Party Auto Property Damage - South Florida

Founded in 1989, United Automobile Insurance Company is an innovative and established organization looking for a Subrogation Counsel (First Party Auto Property Damage) to join our team. Family-owned, UAIC, is one of the largest privately held property and casualty insurance companies in the United States. The key to our growth and success is a commitment to providing quality service to our agents and customers, by providing disciplined underwriting, and strategic claims handling. Our ongoing efforts to invest substantial resources in personnel and technology are the foundation of our promise of assuring maximum efficiency and specialized operations in the industry. We are proud that our independent agents and customers have recognized our dedication by making UAIC the market leader in every state where we conduct business.

Preferred candidate must be in the Miami Dade or Broward County area and accessible to the Miami Dade County and Broward County Courthouse. 

SCOPE

As a Subrogation Counsel (First Party Auto Property Damage) for UAIC, you will be responsible for managing and litigating first‑party auto property damage subrogation claims, representing the company in recovery actions against adverse carriers, at‑fault drivers, vehicle owners, and other responsible parties. You will oversee all phases of the litigation and arbitration process, including pre‑suit investigations, drafting legal documents, conducting discovery, and appearing in court, mediation, and Arbitration Forums proceedings.

This role requires close collaboration with the claims department to ensure legal compliance, evaluate liability, mitigate risk, and negotiate settlements. You will provide legal guidance on Florida auto insurance laws, subrogation rights, and recovery strategy while staying current on statutory and case law developments. This position is remote, offering flexibility while maintaining a high level of engagement with internal teams and external parties.

DUTIES

• Manage and litigate auto property damage subrogation claims, including collision, comprehensive, UM/UIM PD, and PIP reimbursement matters.
• Represent the company in all phases of litigation, from pre‑suit investigation through trial and post‑judgment recovery.
• Develop case strategies; draft pleadings, motions, discovery, and legal memoranda; and attend depositions, hearings, mediations, arbitrations, and trials.
• Provide expert legal advice to the claims department and management regarding auto liability, subrogation potential, and recovery strategy.
• Identify and evaluate claims for subrogation opportunities by assessing liability, comparative negligence, and recovery prospects against third parties.
• Pursue subrogation recoveries through direct negotiation with adverse carriers, Arbitration Forums filings, and litigation when necessary.
• Ensure all actions comply with Florida statutes, insurance regulations, and civil procedure requirements.
• Advise on legal risks related to policy interpretation, settlement decisions, and potential exposure.
• Participate in mediations, arbitrations, and settlement conferences with a focus on maximizing recovery outcomes.
• Conduct legal research on Florida auto subrogation, property damage law, and relevant statutory and appellate developments.
• Prepare clear, concise, and persuasive legal documents, including briefs, memoranda, arbitration contentions, and opinions.
• Stay current with changes in Florida insurance law, auto property damage statutes, and subrogation‑related regulations.
• Collaborate with adjusters and internal legal teams to provide proactive, responsive legal support.

EDUCATION

• Juris Doctor (JD) from an accredited law school.
• Admission to the Florida Bar in good standing.
• Bilingual in English and Spanish is highly desirable.

SKILLS & EXPERIENCE

• Minimum 3–5 years of experience in auto property damage subrogation, insurance litigation, or P&C insurance defense.
• Strong knowledge of Florida auto insurance law, property damage statutes, and litigation procedures.
• Proven litigation experience; trial experience preferred.
• Excellent negotiation, oral advocacy, and legal writing skills.
• Ability to manage a high‑volume caseload and prioritize effectively.
• Proficiency with case management systems, legal research tools, and Microsoft Office.
• Experience representing insurance carriers in first‑party auto claims.

Please note that the salary range listed is an estimate provided by the job board and might not align with accurate information. The actual salary for this position may vary based on experience and qualifications. Candidates are encouraged to discuss compensation during the interview process.

UAIC participates in the E-Verify program to confirm the employment eligibility of all newly hired employees. For more information about E-Verify, please visit  https://www.e-verify.gov/.

UAIC is an Equal Opportunity Employer and is committed to the principle of equal employment opportunity for all employees. All employment decisions at UAIC are based on business needs, job requirements, and individual qualifications, without regard to race, color, religion, or belief, family or parental status, or any other status protected by the laws or regulations in the locations where we operate.