Demo

Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist, Religious Organizations

The Mutual Group
Wisconsin, WI Full Time
POSTED ON 6/2/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 7/1/2026
Department

Field Underwriting

Job Description

As an Underwriting Specialist, you are responsible for managing a book of business for profitability and growth. You will review both new and/or renewal business, assess risk of coverage, prepare quotes and respond to coverage questions, within the assigned authority level. In this role you will also build successful relationships with agents to drive increased, positive business flow. To be successful in this role you will work under limited supervision and exercise significant independent judgement in performing work. Based on location and requirements of the role, this position will either be a hybrid or a remote position.

Work Arrangement

  • Employees who live within 30 miles of the TMG home office are expected to follow a hybrid or in-office schedule. The initial training period may require additional in‑office days.

Accountabilities

  • Delivers profitable outcomes on less complex niche business through effective risk selection by:
    • Analyzing, selecting and profitably pricing business with prescriptive terms and conditions of coverage
    • Examining inspection reports, location, risk, financial and other available tools and reports to identify new or unresolved concerns
    • Communicating with Risk Control for inspections, follow ups and service needs for insureds
    • Driving corrective action or remediation strategies on renewal accounts
    • Escalating referrals, in a timely manner, on accounts that need additional review or approval by higher level underwriters
    • Adhering to service expectations and regulatory compliance by the timely release of renewals, non-renewals and conditional notices
Accountable for achieving key performance indicators of the portfolio including:

  • Developing and furthering successful relationships with distribution partners within the portfolio by:
    • Having regularly scheduled portfolio review calls
    • Meeting voice of the customer guidelines
    • Limited travel to distribution partner offices
    • Consistently meeting our voice of the customer standards
    • Coordinating with distribution team to building pipeline, resolve issues, concerns or conflict and oversee change management
    • Communicating regularly with portfolio team members on health of assigned agencies and market conditions that could impact the portfolio

    Cultivate a High Performing Culture

    • Superior customer service and business acumen
    • Mentoring support staff throughout their career development.
    • Conduct peer audits and approve underwriting decisions (LOAs) for lower authority levels.
    • Assist in the training of new hires and internal promotions by providing continuous mentoring and feedback to foster successful employee development.
    • Reviewing, mentoring, and approving referrals for lower authority level associates
    • Perform other related work as assigned.

    Qualifications

    • Bachelor’s degree in business administration, finance or related field of study preferred.
    • Holding or working towards an insurance designation preferred (CPCU, IIA, etc.).
    • Seven years of progressively responsible experience in commercial underwriting, including one to three years in a property and casualty insurance company.
    • Experience writing business for churches or religious affiliated institutions preferred.
    • Broad knowledge of common terms, practices, processes and regulations in the P&C insurance industry.
    • An ability to consistently apply advanced underwriting concepts and practices within the P&C underwriting field.
    • Adept at applying negotiating skills, reasonableness and exercising sound judgment in analysis and decision making processes.
    • Ability to convey clear & concise information to others utilizing excellent verbal and written communication skills.
    • Advanced analytical, problem-solving and decision-making skills.
    • Strong customer service orientation.
    • Advanced knowledge of Microsoft products including a strong foundation in Excel (pivot tables, vlookups, etc.) for the purpose of strategic analysis.
    • Strong attention to numeric and other details.
    • Strong customer service orientation.
    • Organizational skills and ability to manage large work volume and meet tight deadlines.

    Pay Range

    Anticipated Hiring Range:

    • $73,500–$105,000 annual base salary depending on experience, qualifications, and geographic location
    • $81,000–$120,000 annual base salary depending on experience, qualifications, and geographic location in CA, CT, MA, NJ, NY, and PA

    Benefits

    We are proud to offer our full-time regular employees a robust benefits suite that includes:

    • Competitive base salary plus incentive plans for eligible team members
    • 401(K) retirement plan that includes a company match of up to 6% of your eligible salary
    • Free basic life and AD&D, long-term disability and short-term disability insurance
    • Medical, dental and vision plans to meet your unique healthcare needs
    • Wellness incentives
    • Generous time off program that includes personal, holiday and volunteer paid time off
    • Flexible work schedules and hybrid/remote options for eligible positions
    • Educational assistance

    Equal Opportunity Employer

    The Mutual Group is an Equal Opportunity Employer. It is our policy to recruit, hire, train and promote individuals in all job classifications without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, veteran status, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity or any other characteristic protected by law.

    • Know Your Rights: Workplace Discrimination is Illegal
    • Your Rights Under USERRA

    Applicants requiring a reasonable accommodation due to a disability at any stage of the employment application process should contact Talent@themutualgroup.com.

    Employment Verification

    The Mutual Group participates in the E-Verify program and will provide the federal government with your Form I-9 information to confirm that you are authorized to work in the U.S. You are protected from employment discrimination based on your citizenship status and national origin.

    E-Verify Program Overview

    E-Verify Participation Poster

    All offers of employment are contingent upon the successful completion of a background check.

    #TMG

    Salary : $73,500 - $105,000

    If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
    Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

    What is the career path for a Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist, Religious Organizations?

    Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist, Religious Organizations career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
    Income Estimation: 
    $69,261 - $91,404
    Income Estimation: 
    $88,031 - $110,533
    Income Estimation: 
    $94,544 - $118,022
    Income Estimation: 
    $87,462 - $118,395
    Income Estimation: 
    $90,329 - $120,891
    Income Estimation: 
    $96,188 - $130,586
    Income Estimation: 
    $125,552 - $162,907
    Income Estimation: 
    $115,496 - $142,565
    Income Estimation: 
    $108,370 - $134,975
    Income Estimation: 
    $138,359 - $207,086
    Employees: Get a Salary Increase
    View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

    Job openings at The Mutual Group

    • The Mutual Group Boston, MA
    • Department Information Technology Job Description As the Sr. Manager, AI Risk Governance you will be the primary operator of the AI Systems Governance Prog... more
    • 2 Days Ago

    • The Mutual Group Raleigh, NC
    • Department Information Technology Job Description As the Sr. Manager, AI Risk Governance you will be the primary operator of the AI Systems Governance Prog... more
    • 2 Days Ago

    • The Mutual Group Atlanta, GA
    • Department Information Technology Job Description As the Sr. Manager, AI Risk Governance you will be the primary operator of the AI Systems Governance Prog... more
    • 2 Days Ago

    • The Mutual Group Chicago, IL
    • Department Information Technology Job Description As the Sr. Manager, AI Risk Governance you will be the primary operator of the AI Systems Governance Prog... more
    • 2 Days Ago


    Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist, Religious Organizations jobs in the Wisconsin, WI area that may be a better fit.

    • Sentry Blue, OH
    • This role is required to work in Sentry's hybrid model out of the Cincinnatti, OH regional office. What You’ll Do As an Underwriting Support Specialist, yo... more
    • 5 Days Ago

    • Frank Winston Crum Insurance Clearwater, FL
    • FrankCrum is a Top Workplace! Frank Winston Crum Insurance (FWCI) issues Workers’ Compensation and General Liability policies by offering flexible coverage... more
    • 11 Days Ago

    AI Assistant is available now!

    Feel free to start your new journey!