Demo

Customer Service Supervisor, Insurance Agency

Tesla
Draper, UT Full Time
POSTED ON 6/4/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 7/3/2026
What To Expect
The Insurance Agency Supervisor plays a critical leadership role in driving team performance and operational excellence within Tesla Insurance. Primary responsibilities include managing and developing a high-performing team of licensed insurance agents, prioritizing key business objectives, and serving as a strong advocate for both agents and customers alike.

In this position, you will lead a team of licensed insurance agents at one of our Tesla Insurance locations in Austin, TX, Draper, UT, or Henderson, NV.

The core purpose of the Insurance Agency Supervisor is to ensure your team consistently delivers outstanding performance aligned with their role expectations. By doing so, you directly support Tesla’s mission—accelerating the growth of Tesla Insurance while helping more customers get behind the wheel of a Tesla vehicle.

What You'll Do

  • Manage daily team operations, including adherence to schedules (breaks, lunches, and phone availability)
  • Conduct regular 1:1 meetings to review performance, provide feedback, and support development
  • Document coaching, performance feedback, and corrective actions through internal systems
  • Partner with HR on hiring and performance management
  • Support agents in real-time with complex customer situations
  • Handle escalated customer interactions, including safety score disputes, billing concerns, and pricing inquiries
  • Collaborate with agency leadership to improve policies, procedures, and performance expectations


  • What You'll Bring

  • Minimum of 3 years leadership experience within an insurance agency environment
  • Active Property and Casualty (P&C) or Personal Lines license in the state of domicile, plus non-resident licenses in all other states where required
  • Strong knowledge of insurance policies, processes, and industry practices
  • Excellent communication and interpersonal skills
  • Ability to multitask, prioritize, and manage competing priorities
  • Strong critical thinking and problem-solving skills
  • Experience de-escalating customer concerns effectively


  • Benefits
    Compensation and Benefits
    Along with competitive pay, as a full-time Tesla employee, you are eligible for the following benefits at day 1 of hire:
  • Medical plans > plan options with $0 payroll deduction
  • Family-building, fertility, adoption and surrogacy benefits
  • Dental (including orthodontic coverage) and vision plans, both have options with a $0 paycheck contribution
  • Company Paid (Health Savings Accounts) HSA Contribution when enrolled in the High-Deductible medical plan with HSA
  • Healthcare and Dependent Care Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA)
  • 401(k) with employer match, Employee Stock Purchase Plans, and other financial benefits
  • Company paid Basic Life, AD&D
  • Short-term and long-term disability insurance (90 day waiting period)
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • Sick and Vacation time (Flex time for salary positions, Accrued hours for Hourly positions), and Paid Holidays
  • Back-up childcare and parenting support resources
  • Voluntary benefits to include: critical illness, hospital indemnity, accident insurance, theft & legal services, and pet insurance
  • Weight Loss and Tobacco Cessation Programs
  • Tesla Babies program
  • Commuter benefits
  • Employee discounts and perks program


  • , Tesla

    Salary.com Estimation for Customer Service Supervisor, Insurance Agency in Draper, UT
    $101,745 to $121,186
    If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
    Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

    What is the career path for a Customer Service Supervisor, Insurance Agency?

    Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Customer Service Supervisor, Insurance Agency career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
    Income Estimation: 
    $103,668 - $124,003
    Income Estimation: 
    $117,366 - $147,956
    Income Estimation: 
    $113,122 - $140,555
    Income Estimation: 
    $156,966 - $210,205
    Employees: Get a Salary Increase
    View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

    Job openings at Tesla

    • Tesla Kahului, HI
    • What To Expect As a Tesla Technician, you become a vital part of our global team, working towards our mission of accelerating the world's transition to sus... more
    • Just Posted

    • Tesla Sparks, NV
    • What To Expect Tesla is seeking a highly motivated Equipment Engineer to contribute to the development and improvement of new automation equipment and asse... more
    • Just Posted

    • Tesla Sparks, NV
    • What To Expect As a Controls Technician, you will play a crucial role to support our production operations. This role is responsible for maintaining, troub... more
    • Just Posted

    • Tesla Sparks, NV
    • What To Expect As a Tesla Maintenance Planner, you will play a crucial role in ensuring the operational availability of a wide array of manufacturing equip... more
    • Just Posted


    Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Customer Service Supervisor, Insurance Agency jobs in the Draper, UT area that may be a better fit.

    • Tesla Motors, Inc. Draper, UT
    • What to Expect The Insurance Agency Supervisor plays a critical leadership role in driving team performance and operational excellence within Tesla Insuran... more
    • 2 Months Ago

    • WCF Insurance Sandy, UT
    • WCF Insurance's small business team has an immediate opening for a full-time Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative - Front Desk & Chat who can d... more
    • 25 Days Ago

    AI Assistant is available now!

    Feel free to start your new journey!