Total Rewards Manager

Total Rewards Manager

Randolph, MA | Human Resources 

Help Reward the People Who Power Our Mission 

At May Institute, our employees make life-changing work possible for individuals with autism and other developmental disabilities. The Total Rewards Manager plays a key role in ensuring our team is supported through competitive, equitable, and meaningful compensation, benefits, and recognition programs. 

Reporting to the VP of Corporate HR & HR Operations, this role leads the strategy, design, and administration of total rewards programs and partners with leaders across the organization to strengthen attraction, retention, and employee experience. 

What You’ll Do 

Total Rewards Strategy 

• Develop and maintain a comprehensive total rewards framework integrating compensation, benefits, wellness, and recognition 

• Evaluate program performance using market data, analytics, and employee feedback to drive improvements 

Benefits & Well-Being 

• Oversee health, welfare, retirement, leave, and voluntary benefit programs 

• Manage vendor relationships, plan renewals, and open enrollment 

• Monitor program utilization, costs, and service levels 

• Improve benefits communications to help employees understand and maximize their offerings 

Compensation & Pay Governance 

• Maintain salary structures, job evaluations, and market pricing across clinical and non-clinical roles 

• Partner with HR leaders on offers, promotions, retention strategies, and annual compensation planning 

• Support pay equity initiatives and workforce planning through data analysis 

Data & Systems 

• Maintain accurate compensation and benefits data in HR systems (Dayforce experience preferred) 

• Develop reports and dashboards to support leadership decisions and workforce insights 

Leadership & Partnership 

• Serve as the organization’s subject matter expert on total rewards 

• Partner with HR Business Partners and Finance to support workforce strategy 

What You’ll Bring 

• Bachelor’s degree in HR, Business, Finance, or related field 

• 5–7 years of progressive experience in compensation, benefits, or total rewards 

• Experience managing health & welfare benefits, retirement plans, and leave programs 

• Knowledge of compensation structures, job evaluation, FLSA, and pay equity principles 

• Strong analytical skills with advanced Excel and HRIS experience (Workday preferred) 

• Ability to translate complex compensation and benefits concepts into clear guidance for leaders 

Preferred: CCP, CBP, SHRM-CP, or SHRM-SCP certification and experience in a mission-driven or healthcare organization. 

Why Join May Institute 

• Generous Paid Time Off: Vacation, 10 holidays, 19 PTO days to start, plus a floating birthday holiday 

• Comprehensive Health Coverage: Medical, dental, and vision options 

• Retirement Benefits: 403(b) with employer match 

• Education Support: Tuition reimbursement and student loan repayment assistance 

• Professional Growth: Ongoing learning and development opportunities 

• Employee Support: Confidential Employee Assistance Program (EAP) 

Join May Institute and help design the rewards that support the people who make our mission possible.