Demo

Personal Lines Agency Marketing Manager

Sentry
Indianapolis, IN Full Time
POSTED ON 4/9/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/7/2026
Agency Sales Managers are responsible for agency selection through identification of qualified agency partnerships for our non-standard auto and powersports Personal Lines Insurance.

If you are in Kentucky and have the passion to unleash your talent, the drive to build new relationships, are a motivated self-starter and have strong organizational skills this is a great opportunity for you on our Agency Sales Team.

Based on qualifications and experience, this position can be filled as an Agency Sales Manager I, Agency Sales Manager II, or Agency Sales Manager Senior.

What You'll Do

As the Agency Sales Manager you will be responsible for implementing plans to contribute to the achievement of agency produced sales, premium and loss ratio objectives. In addition, you’ll:

  • Oversee agency sales in the state of Kentucky and Indiana
  • Develop rapport to develop profitable business
  • Provide comprehensive sales expertise to agents to increase production
  • Develop new and enhance existing agent premium sources to achieve sales and premium objectives
  • Oversee agency selection, suspension, and terminations

What It Takes

  • Bachelor’s degree preferred or equivalent work experience
  • 0-5 years of related work experience in the insurance industry, with familiarity of non-standard auto, motorcycle or powersports products
  • Sales experience and knowledge of professional sales techniques
  • Effective human relations and communication skills
  • Ability to meet travel requirements of this job – The expectation during normal operations in this position will be up to 4 days a week travel within your territory with overnight travel required when necessary.
  • Acceptable Motor Vehicle Record and valid driver’s license

What You'll Receive

At Sentry, your total rewards go beyond competitive compensation. Below are some benefits and perks that you’ll receive.

  • Company car and gas card
  • Cell phone stipend
  • Continue your education and career development through Sentry University (SentryU) and utilize our Tuition Reimbursement program
  • Generous Paid-Time Off plan for you to enjoy time out of the office as well as Volunteer-Time off
  • Group Medical, Dental, Vision, Life insurance, Parental leave, and our Health and Wellness benefits to encourage a healthy lifestyle.
  • Well-being and Employee Assistance programs
  • Sentry Foundation gift matching program to encourage charitable giving.

About Sentry

We take great pride in making Forbes’ list of America’s Best Midsize Employers. A lot of different factors go into that honor, many of which contribute to your job satisfaction.

Our bright future is built on a long track record of success. We got our start in 1904 and have been helping businesses succeed and protect their futures ever since. Because of the trust placed in us, we’re one of the largest and financially strongest mutual insurance companies in the United States. We’re rated A by A.M. Best, the industry's leading rating authority.

Our headquarters is in Stevens Point, Wisconsin, with offices located throughout the United States. From sales to claims, and information technology to marketing, we enjoy a rewarding and challenging work environment with opportunities for ongoing professional development and growth.

Get ready to own your future at Sentry. Opportunities await!

Casey Van Der Geest

Casey.VanDerGeest@sentry.com

Equal Employment Opportunity

Sentry is an Equal Opportunity Employer. It is our policy that there be no discrimination in employment based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, age, marital status, or sexual orientation.

Salary.com Estimation for Personal Lines Agency Marketing Manager in Indianapolis, IN
$91,570 to $120,770
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Personal Lines Agency Marketing Manager?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Personal Lines Agency Marketing Manager career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$115,898 - $155,468
Income Estimation: 
$160,561 - $207,658
Income Estimation: 
$99,713 - $138,140
Income Estimation: 
$122,633 - $166,569
Income Estimation: 
$116,413 - $176,962
Income Estimation: 
$96,354 - $147,227
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Sentry

  • Sentry Davenport, IA
  • Kick off your career at The General! Dive into real auto claims from day one, gain hands-on training, assess liability, and grow into a confident, knowledg... more
  • 9 Days Ago

  • Sentry Louisville, KY
  • Agency Sales Managers are responsible for agency selection through identification of qualified agency partnerships for our non-standard auto and powersport... more
  • 9 Days Ago

  • Sentry Evansville, IN
  • Agency Sales Managers are responsible for agency selection through identification of qualified agency partnerships for our non-standard auto and powersport... more
  • 9 Days Ago

  • Sentry Nashville, TN
  • The State Product Manager-Nonstandard Auto is responsible for increasing profit, premium, & market share while meeting customers’ needs in an assigned regi... more
  • 9 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Personal Lines Agency Marketing Manager jobs in the Indianapolis, IN area that may be a better fit.

  • Shepherd Insurance Carmel, IN
  • Description PURPOSE: This is an ideal opportunity to work at a growing organization with a strong family culture. Shepherd Insurance is a privately-owned i... more
  • 16 Days Ago

  • Conner Insurance Inc Indianapolis, IN
  • JOB SUMMARY AND PURPOSE The Personal Lines, Account Manager position is crucial to the day-to-day operations and long-term goals of the Personal Lines Depa... more
  • Just Posted

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!