Demo

Production Supervisor - 2nd Shift

Organic Valley
Organic Valley Salary
Chaseburg, WI Intern
POSTED ON 4/15/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/14/2026
Location – This is an onsite role that works at the Chaseburg Creamery in Chaseburg, WI. This position supervisors 2nd shift production, Monday-Friday from 2pm-11pm.

Employee Type – Salaried

Bonus – This position is eligible for a 5% annual incentive bonus based on cooperative and individual performance.

Safety Sensitive – Yes

If a company is going to make a difference in today’s world, it’s going to have to think differently. At Organic Valley, our philosophy and decisions are based on the health and welfare of people, animals and the earth. We’re a mission-driven cooperative, owned by family farmers, and we’ve been leaders in organic agriculture from the very beginning. Once pioneers of organic agriculture, we’re now an established leader. Organic is all we do. We are driven by our mission to promote regional farm diversity and economic stability by the means of organic agricultural methods and the sale of certified organic products.

Summary Of Role

The Production Supervisor is responsible for directing and supervising the efficient operations of production, packaging, and sanitation at the Chaseburg Creamery. This role promotes collaboration and teamwork within the production team members and with others in the facility to foster motivation, increased productivity, and ensure the highest level of customer service. This is a safety sensitive role. The Creamery is open 365 days a year including holidays.

Essential Duties And Responsibilities

  • Communicates performance expectations by evaluating performance, providing timely feedback, training, and coaching, and recommending personnel actions for assigned staff.
  • Ensures compliance with applicable policies, safety policies/procedures/best practices, and fair employment practices.
  • Ensure that staff follows good manufacturing, safety, and quality assurance policies and practices.
  • Ensure staff members are working in compliance of HACCP program and BRC audit guidelines.
  • Coordinates staff schedules to meet production requirements.
  • In conjunction with other supervisors, production manager, assistant plant manager, and plant manager; oversee day-to-day operations of the Butter, Intake and HTST teams.
  • Ensures production and sanitation records are completed accurately and timely and reviews records on a routine basis.
  • Manage and participate as needed with the input of milk, and butter production into SAP, Excel spreadsheets, milk receiving program and SCADA software.
  • Review operations with the Plant Manager, Assistant Plant Manager, Production Manager, Senior Quality Assurance Field Manager, and production staff to resolve production and/or sanitation problems.
  • Coordinate and initiate procedures for facility upkeep, cleanup, and equipment maintenance.
  • Assist with internal GMP audits and/or any BRC/customer audits.
  • Delegate and complete corrective and preventative actions.
  • Review and approval of time off and timecards for direct staff.
  • Create, review, and update work instructions, SOP’s and approved forms as needed.
  • Work as a team with other supervisors to provide supervision and support of production staff.

Additional Duties And Responsibilities

  • Collaborate with other plant supervisors and staff to continuously improve production and sanitation at the Chaseburg Creamery.
  • Other duties as assigned by supervisor.

Knowledge, Skills, And Abilities

  • Minimum of three years of production related experience, preferably in the food production or sanitation field in the dairy industry.
  • Minimum of one year of experience coordinating, supervising, or training employees in a production or manufacturing environment.
  • Ability to frequently lift/carry up to 60 pounds, occasionally lift (up to) 80 pounds with assistance, ability to push/pull up to 2,500 pounds using material handling equipment.
  • Ability to stand for extended periods of time.
  • Ability to occasionally bend, twist/turn, reach above shoulders, and climb throughout the shift as needed.
  • Proven ability to lead, motivate and coach a diverse workforce.
  • Demonstrated knowledge and ability to work with required sanitation chemicals.
  • Demonstrated competency and understanding of Good Manufacturing Practices.
  • Strong oral and written communication and comprehension skills.
  • Proven proficiency with inductive and deductive reasoning, problem solving, troubleshooting, and attention to detail.
  • Good computer skills required; experience with Microsoft Outlook, Excel, and Word preferred.
  • Ability to work in a team environment.
  • Ability to handle confidentiality in a professional and appropriate manner.
  • Ability to multitask and operate under pressure.
  • Ability to work a flexible schedule, as needed.
  • Ability to read and interpret critical information and follow specific instructions.

Base salary range: $67,516.80 - $81,827.20 per year

This salary range is exclusive of fringe benefits. The compensation package may also include incentive compensation opportunities in the form of discretionary bonuses. If you are hired at CROPP, your final base salary compensation will be determined based on factors such as skills, education, and/or experience. Additionally, we believe in the importance of pay equity and consider the internal equity of our current team members as a part of any final offer. Please keep in mind that entry-level candidates to this role should expect to be at the lower end of the salary range and hiring at the maximum of the salary range is not typical.

Benefits

We believe when our people are strong, our mission is strong. Therefore, we offer a comprehensive and holistic Total Rewards package meant to strengthen employees’ and their family's total wellbeing. Here are some of the great benefits offered:

  • Comprehensive Health Insurance - Choice of plans for you and your family, including some that can be paired with an HSA (which CROPP contributes to on your behalf)
  • Supplemental insurances: we offer accidental insurance, critical illness insurance, and hospital indemnity insurance.
  • Time Off – 136 hours in the 1st year of employment prorated by start date. Plus 9 paid holidays, plus one floating holiday to use at will.
  • 6 Weeks Paid Parental Leave – For all gendered partners in childbirth or adoption.
  • Vision & Dental Insurance – Free annual eye exam, discounts on glasses/contacts, flexible dental network, adult ortho.
  • 401k – We match 100% up to the first 3% of an employee’s contribution, and then 50% for 3.1%-5.0% of employee contributions.
  • Free services at five local Neighborhood Family Clinics.
  • Tuition Reimbursement – Up to $1,500 per year to support continuing higher education.
  • Life Insurance - $50,000 policy funded by CROPP for each employee. Supplemental voluntary coverage available for employees, spouses, and children.
  • Short-Term & Long-Term Disability/AD&D Insurance - $50,000 of life insurance coverage of $50,000 of AD&D coverage funded by CROPP for each employee.
  • Employee Assistance Program - Free and Confidential for employees, spouses, and dependents.
  • Free biometric screenings (cholesterol, glucose, blood pressure) and health coaching.
  • Financial advisors and seminars
  • Annual $360 Lifestyle Spending Account
  • Flexible Scheduling

Salary : $67,517 - $81,827

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Organic Valley

  • Organic Valley Chaseburg, WI
  • Production Float - Mon/Tues & e/o Fri-Sun, 6am-6pm Location - Thisis an onsite role that works at the Chaseburg Creamery in Chaseburg, WI. This position wo... more
  • 1 Day Ago

  • Organic Valley McMinnville, OR
  • Location – This is an onsite role that works in McMinnville, Oregon. The shift/hours are Monday and Thursday 5pm-5:30am and Tuesday and Friday 5pm-1:30am. ... more
  • 2 Days Ago

  • Organic Valley Viroqua, WI
  • Location – This role is based out of the Organic Valley Trucking Garage in Viroqua, WI. Drivers are home nightly. Overtime and weekend rotation. Employee T... more
  • 2 Days Ago

  • Organic Valley Chaseburg, WI
  • Hiring Manager/Recruiter – Emily Allen, Human Relations Business Partner Manager Location – Low Hybrid This is a hybrid role, which means that you will hav... more
  • 3 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Production Supervisor - 2nd Shift jobs in the Chaseburg, WI area that may be a better fit.

  • gpac La Crosse, WI
  • We are seeking a Production Supervisor for 1st shift in Vernon County, Wisconsin. This well-established food manufacturing company has been producing fresh... more
  • 4 Days Ago

  • City Brewing Co La Crosse, WI
  • City Brewing Company – Who We Are With our roots in La Crosse, WI, we are proud to be North America’s largest co-packager of alcoholic beverages with four ... more
  • 17 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!