Demo

Insurance Sales Agent for Existing Book of Business - Toledo, Ohio

Lightwell Insurance Advisors of Washington
Toledo, OH Full Time
POSTED ON 11/3/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 3/1/2027

Exciting sales opportunity in the commercial property & casualty insurance industry taking over an existing book of business serving churches and ministries. In this role you will be responsible for growing new business (75% of time) among pre-identified prospects while servicing the existing book of business (25% of time) among the agency’s current church and faith-based non-profit clients. Successful commercial insurance experience, ideally working for an Insurance Retail Agency or Company, is necessary to apply for this opportunity.

Our ideal candidate:

  • Has a heart for serving ministries and non-profit organizations
  • Lives in the Greater Toledo, Ohio area
  • Possesses exceptional relational skills and a desire to build strong, trusting relationships with clients
  • Has years of success selling commercial insurance (personal insurance experience will also be considered)
  • A current Property & Casualty insurance agent license

You must be:

  • An ambitious self-starter with a faith testimony
  • Able to work remotely and conduct field prospecting, sales, and service calls daily
  • A hunter with the ability to establish rapport and build new relationships
  • Detail oriented and receptive to coaching
  • Comfortable to being held accountable to performance goals
  • Able to work independently and with a team
  • Motivated to help others

To the qualified insurance producer, we offer:

  • Base salary plus bonuses that increases with growth in your book of business
  • 100% employer paid health, life, disability, dental and vision insurance for individual (dependent coverage is employer paid at a contributary level)
  • Automobile mileage reimbursement
  • Company-funded retirement account

Income: $70,000 - $85,000

Job Summary:

The candidate will report directly to the Sales Manager of Lightwell - Ohio and will be responsible for generating commercial insurance sales with both current and new church and non-profit clients via phone calls, personal visits and attending events.

You will be accountable for prospecting activity metrics and performance against sales targets while providing exceptional customer service.

You will also help with marketing efforts by keeping abreast of and reporting on industry trends, competition, and market conditions

Qualifications:

  • Bachelor’s degree or high school degree with equivalent business/work experience
  • Three or more years’ success in insurance sales, preferably in commercial property & casualty insurance
  • A current Property & Casualty insurance license is required
  • Prior experience as a volunteer or employee of a church is a plus

About:

The Lightwell Insurance Advisors – Ohio specializes in insurance and risk management for Christian churches, camps, and ministries plus other non-profits. Our insurance specialists are dedicated to helping churches and ministries find the right insurance coverage to meet their unique needs in Ohio. Lightwell Insurance Advisors – Ohio represents Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, a company that has been dedicated to insuring churches and related ministries for more than 100 years.

Job Type: Permanent

Pay: $70,000.00 - $85,000.00 per year

Benefits:

  • 401(k) matching
  • Dental insurance
  • Disability insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Paid time off
  • Vision insurance

Application Question(s):

  • Please describe your relationship with organized churches and/or ministries in a few short sentences. Please note you must answer this question, or your application will not be considered!

Experience:

  • Commercial Insurance sales: 3 years (Preferred)

License/Certification:

  • Property & Casualty License (Required)

Work Location: On the road

Salary : $70,000 - $85,000

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Insurance Sales Agent for Existing Book of Business - Toledo, Ohio jobs in the Toledo, OH area that may be a better fit.

  • Bankers Life Toledo, OH
  • Are you driven by a highly competitive compensation structure? Is securing your financial independence and inspiring others to do the same important to you... more
  • 20 Days Ago

  • Girl Scouts of Western Ohio Toledo, OH
  • BUSINESS OPERATIONS SPECIALIST SUMMARY/OBJECTIVE The Business Operations Specialist plays a vital role in supporting the organization’s business administra... more
  • 18 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!