Demo

Ian's Pizza Milwaukee - Shift Leader

Ian's Pizza
Milwaukee, WI Other
POSTED ON 4/15/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 6/12/2026

Ian's Pizza

Ian's brings affordable, craft-quality pizza to the people. We use the finest local ingredients to make the best NY-style, hand-tossed 'za to hit your tastebuds. Specializing in old-school and original combinations, all available by the slice or whole pie.

Ian's is the ultimate destination for dreamers and problem-solvers, whether you want to open your own business someday, or are just seeing where life takes you. You'll gain transferable skills all while making life-long friends and earning some sweet tips along the way!

  • Competitive Wages: A shift supervisor starts at an hourly wage of $14-$15/hour, depending on location, paid biweekly. For in-store (non-catering and offsites) positions, we also offer an additional $1/hour for any time worked after 11pm and anytime worked on Sundays, which is included in your paycheck.
  • Superb Tips: Tips average to $3-8/hour, depending on the shift and location. Money in your pocket at the end of each shift! This means your average hourly take home is $17-$23/hour. For Offsite and Event Shift Leading, tips average more in the $5-$15/hour, and are either paid on your check or at the end of the shift depending on the location.
  • Excellent Benefits: Affordable, top-notch health and dental care, retirement benefits, PTO accrual after a year, profit-sharing, flexible schedules, and free food.
  • Inclusive Culture: We are committed to caring for our people and community. Our Big Five guides us in how we interact with one another: Dependability, Awareness, Connection, Generosity, and Effort.
  • Off-site and Catering Opportunities: Nothing beats a Milwaukee summer, and we take full advantage by selling pizza around town! Events add variety, and the tips are *chef's kiss*! Seriously, you could pocket an extra $5-$20 bucks an hour just in tips!

Restaurant Shift Supervisor Duties

You are the "big cheese" on shift! Your job is all about making sure everything runs smoothly. That means getting orders just right and making sure they're ready right on time, serving up top-notch food, and making every customer feel like a VIP. You make sure everything on the to-do list gets checked off, and everyone's in the right place at the right time. As a Shift Supervisor, you'll even get to help train new folks and attend regular Shift Leader team meetings. πŸ§€πŸ‘‘

  • External candidates must have 1 years of supervisory experience in food service or customer service. Internal candidates must have a minimum of 3 months' experience with the company and be an employee in good standing who has completed all initial General Staff training classes.
  • Cross-trained in, or has a solid understanding of, all restaurant departments is preferred.
  • Be able to stand and walk for long periods.
  • Be able to bend, crouch, and lift to 20-50 lbs.
  • Be able to use ovens, pizza cutters, and other equipment of the business.
  • English language proficiency is required for this position.
  • Must be 18 to apply. If you are 16 or 17 years old, you can apply for the Front of House at our Story Hill location (5300 W Bluemound Road) or for a Seasonal Summer Catering and Offsites position. All other positions/locations require you to be 18 years of age.
  • Must be authorized to work in the United States and able to provide adequate identification documentation at Orientation and/or Day One. For more information, you can visit https://www.uscis.gov/i-9.

Restaurant Shift Supervisor Scheduling

9-5 is a Dolly Parton song, not a job at Ian's Pizza! Opening shifts typically start 1-2 hours before opening, and closing shifts typically wrap up 1-2 hours after closing. For Catering and Offsite events, most shifts start 1-2 hours before the event time and end at about the end time of the event or just after. Most employees work a mix of shifts (open, mids, dinner, closing). For more hours information, please check out our website at ianspizza.com.

Our restaurants and catering/offsites are most busy on evenings and weekends, so availability for these shifts is strongly preferred. If you are looking for full-time hours, your availability should be mostly open and flexible.

Part-time (anywhere in the 15-30 hours a week range) or full-time (30-40 hours a week) is available. We'll try our hardest to give you the hours and shifts you want, but we can't promise the same schedule every week. For full-timers though, we'll make sure you average 30-40 hours each week to ensure your health and dental benefits eligibility.

Wannabe a first mate on the S.S. Pizza Party?

If you're passionate about good food, great vibes, and excellent tips and benefits... apply today for the Shift Leader position! The best place to apply to ensure we see your application as soon as possible is on our website at ianspizza.com. We are looking forward to meeting you!

Want to learn more about Ian's Pizza and the unique culture of our restaurants? We want you to visit us, check out our website, follow us on Instagram or Facebook, or look at our Indeed.com page for employee reviews!

Salary : $3 - $8

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs with skills like those required for the Ian's Pizza Milwaukee - Shift Leader.

Click the checkbox next to the jobs that you are interested in.

  • Customer Service Skill

    • Income Estimation: $43,569 - $82,025
    • Income Estimation: $47,269 - $68,543
  • Delivery Management Skill

    • Income Estimation: $87,731 - $109,164
    • Income Estimation: $91,493 - $131,263
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Ian's Pizza

  • Ian's Pizza Madison, WI
  • Join the Ian's Pizza Team as an Assistant General Manager! We're not just offering a job; this is a pathway for you to grow as a leader. Our training progr... more
  • 1 Day Ago

  • Ian's Pizza Milwaukee, WI
  • Join the Ian's Pizza Team as an Assistant General Manager We're not just offering a job; this is a pathway for you to grow as a leader. Our training progra... more
  • 7 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Ian's Pizza Milwaukee - Shift Leader jobs in the Milwaukee, WI area that may be a better fit.

  • Ian's Pizza Milwaukee, WI
  • Join the Ian's Pizza Team as an Assistant General Manager We're not just offering a job; this is a pathway for you to grow as a leader. Our training progra... more
  • 7 Days Ago

  • Ian's Pizza Milwaukee, WI
  • We're hiring restaurant crew members at Ian's Pizza Story Hill to serve up our legendary NY-style pies, learn new skills, and have fun while earning $15-$1... more
  • 1 Month Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!