Demo

Complex Claims Examiner

Heritage MGA LLC
Tampa, FL Full Time
POSTED ON 12/3/2025
AVAILABLE BEFORE 2/3/2026
Complex Claims Examiner


This is an in office role. We have an opportunity to hire in either Sunrise, FL or Tampa, FL. 

Manages complex and/or large exposure files to bring them to resolution. Analyzes and reviews claims for accuracy, completeness and eligibility. Resolves claims by investigating losses, calculating and negotiating settlements. Prepares and maintains reports and records for processing. 

Investigates, evaluates, reserves, negotiates and settles assigned claims in accordance with Best Practices. Provides quality claim handling and superior customer service on assigned claims, while engaging in indemnity and expense management. Promptly manages claims by completing essential functions including contacts, investigations, damages development, evaluations, reserving, litigation management, and disposition.

Essential Duties and Responsibilities:

  • Handles 1st party property claims within all Heritage Companies states of moderate severity and complexity along with claims with large exposures as assigned, with little direction and oversight.
  • Delivers outstanding customer service to all internal, external, current, and prospective Heritage Companies customers. Adheres to high standards of professional conduct while providing delivery of outstanding claim's service.
  • Conducts timely coverage analysis and communication with insured based on application of policy information, facts or allegations of each case. Consults with Unit Manager on use of Claim Coverage Counsel.
  • Performs detailed investigations and evaluates all relevant facts to determine coverage, damages and liability of first-party property damage claims (including but not limited to analyzing leases, contracts, by-laws and other relevant documents which may have an impact), damages, and liability of first-party property claims under a variety of policies. Secures recorded or written statements as appropriate.
  • Identifies resources for specific activities required to properly investigate claims such as Subro, Fire or Fraud investigators and other experts. Requests through Unit Manager and coordinate the results of their efforts and findings.
  • Verifies the nature and extent of injury or property damage by obtaining and reviewing appropriate records and damages documentation.
  • Maintains diary system, capturing all required data and documents claim file activities in accordance with established company guidelines.
  • Responsible for prompt, cost effective, and proper disposition of all claims within delegated authority.
  • Manages file inventory to ensure timely resolution of claims. Reports on pending claims and findings to the Claims Manager
  • Communicate and interact with a variety of individuals to foster the timely resolution of claims, including, but not limited to, policyholders, public adjusters, attorneys, vendors, and experts.
  • Reviews the insurance policy contract, policy endorsements and related documents to make a proper coverage determination.
  • Opens, closes, and adjusts reserves according to company practices to ensure reserve adequacy. Adheres to file conferencing notification and authority procedures.
  • Settles claim by determining insurance carrier’s liability and negotiating agreement with appropriate parties according to company policy provisions.
  • Collects, updates and maintains all claim documentation including statements, pictures, reports, estimates, etc. and verifies the accuracy and completeness of claim forms.
  • Negotiates disposition of claims with insured and claimants or their legal representatives. Recognizes and implements alternate means of resolution.
  • Attends depositions, EUOs, mediations, arbitrations, pre-trials, trials and all other legal proceedings, as needed.
  • Attends large loss meetings to discuss any claim concerns, and prepares any claim review forms as needed. 
  • Updates appropriate parties as needed, providing new facts as they become available, and their impact upon the liability analysis and settlement options.
  • Write denial letters, Reservation of Rights and other complex correspondence.
  • Maintains current knowledge of local industry repair procedures and local market pricing.
  • Maintains compliance with Claim Department's Best Practices.
  • Represent the company as a technical resource, attend legal proceedings as needed, act within established professional guidelines as well as applicable state laws
  • Supports workload surges and/or Catastrophe operations as needed to include working significant overtime during designated CATs.
  • May coach, counsel, and/or train less-experienced staff.
  • Assist management when required with projects or leadership requests including travel as needed.
  • May act as back up in leadership absence.
  • Some overnight travel may be required.
  • Maintains the integrity of the company and products offered by complying with federal and state regulations as well as company policies and procedures.

Job Qualifications:

  • Bachelor’s Degree preferred. A combination of education and significant directly related experience may be considered in lieu of degree.
  • 6-20 Licensure required.
  • Will be required to obtain Adjuster License in all Heritage Companies states.
  • Three to five years of experience processing claims; property and casualty segment preferred.
  • Experience with Xactware products preferred.
  • Flexibility to work nontraditional hours.
  • Demonstrated ability to research, conduct proactive investigations and negotiate successful resolutions.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office products required; internet research tools preferred.
  • Demonstrated customer service focus / superior customer service skills.
  • Excellent communication skills and ability to interact on a professional level with internal and external personnel
  • Results driven with strong problem solving and analytical skills.
  • Ability to work independently in a fast paced environment; meets deadlines, and manages changing priorities effectively.
  • Detail-oriented and exceptionally organized
  • Collaborative partner; ability to contribute to a positive work environment.

General Information:

All employees must pass a pre-employment background check. Other checks may be needed based on position: driving history, credit report, etc.

The preceding job description has been designed to indicate the general nature of work performed; the level of knowledge and skills typically required; and usual working conditions of this position. It is not designed to contain, or be interpreted as, a comprehensive listing of all requirements or responsibilities that may be required by employees in this job. Nothing in this job description restricts management’s right to assign or reassign duties and responsibilities to this job at any time.

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. is an Equal Opportunity Employer. We will not discriminate unlawfully against qualified applicants or employees with respect to any term or condition of employment based on race, color, national origin, ancestry, sex, sexual orientation, age, religion, physical or mental disability, marital status, place of birth, military service status, or other basis protected by law. 

Salary.com Estimation for Complex Claims Examiner in Tampa, FL
$60,964 to $77,293
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Complex Claims Examiner?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Complex Claims Examiner career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$63,693 - $82,116
Income Estimation: 
$78,860 - $101,439
Income Estimation: 
$97,158 - $125,490
Income Estimation: 
$142,348 - $187,535
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
Income Estimation: 
$63,693 - $82,116
Income Estimation: 
$78,860 - $101,439
Income Estimation: 
$51,115 - $63,458
Income Estimation: 
$58,790 - $76,174
Income Estimation: 
$63,693 - $82,116
Income Estimation: 
$78,860 - $101,439
Income Estimation: 
$94,044 - $119,611
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Heritage MGA LLC

  • Heritage MGA LLC Johnston, RI
  • Claims Examiner Position Summary: Investigates, evaluates, reserves, negotiates and settles assigned claims in accordance with Best Practices. Provides qua... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Heritage MGA LLC Tampa, FL
  • Agency Contracting & Licensing Specialist Location: Tampa, FL Department: Agency Services Employment Type: Full-Time, Non-Exempt, Benefits Eligible(1st of ... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Heritage MGA LLC Tampa, FL
  • MUST HAVE COMMERCIAL CLAIMS EXPERIENCE IN P&C, ACTIVE LICENSE AND BE WILLING TO COME INTO THE OFFICE FULL TIME. We are located at 1401 N Westshore Blvd, Ta... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Heritage MGA LLC Tampa, FL
  • Job Summary: The Associate Risk Analyst position requires an individual with strong analytical skills and abilities to dissect and understand large data se... more
  • 14 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Complex Claims Examiner jobs in the Tampa, FL area that may be a better fit.

  • Heritage Insurance and Careers Tampa, FL
  • Complex Claims Examiner This is an in office role. We have an opportunity to hire in either Sunrise, FL or Tampa, FL. Manages complex and/or large exposure... more
  • 18 Days Ago

  • Heritage MGA LLC Tampa, FL
  • THIS ROLE IS FOR: 1401 N Westshore Blvd, Tampa, FL 33607 The Role is 100% ON SITE Position Summary: Investigates, evaluates, reserves, negotiates and settl... more
  • 1 Month Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!