Demo

Account Manager, Employee Benefits

Gregory & Appel
Indianapolis, IN Full Time
POSTED ON 6/4/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 7/3/2026
Description

We are seeking a highly organized, proactive, and client-focused Employee Benefits Account Manager. This role serves as the primary owner of service execution, renewal timelines, implementations, and day-to-day client support.

Working in partnership with Account Executives, the Account Manager ensures all client deliverables are completed accurately, efficiently, and on schedule. The ideal candidate thrives in a fast-paced environment, excels at managing multiple priorities, and takes ownership of creating an exceptional client experience.

Requirements

Essential Responsibilities

Client Service & Relationship Management

  • Serve as the primary day-to-day contact for assigned clients.
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with client contacts, carrier representatives, and vendor partners.
  • Respond to client inquiries regarding eligibility, billing, claims, plan administration, and other service-related matters.
  • Proactively communicate timelines, deliverables, and next steps to ensure clients remain informed and confident throughout the year.
  • Manage client expectations while delivering a consistent, high-quality service experience.

Renewal Management & Execution

  • Own the renewal process from initiation through implementation.
  • Establish and manage renewal timelines to ensure all deliverables are completed on schedule.
  • Lead renewal execution, carrier marketing efforts, implementation activities, and ongoing service delivery.
  • Prepare renewal analyses, benchmarking reports, presentations, and supporting materials.
  • Partner with Account Executives to execute renewal strategies and recommendations.
  • Document decisions, activities, and renewal progress within agency systems.
  • Attend and participate in client meetings (travel may be required).
  • Present at open enrollment education meetings (travel may be required).

Implementation & Project Management

  • Coordinate implementation activities for new and renewing clients.
  • Manage carrier paperwork, enrollment materials, and implementation timelines.
  • Partner with internal resources and carrier representatives to ensure successful onboarding and transitions.
  • Monitor project milestones and proactively address risks that could impact deadlines or client satisfaction.

Compliance & Industry Knowledge

  • Maintain working knowledge of employee benefits regulations, including ACA, COBRA, ERISA, HIPAA, Section 125, and other applicable requirements.
  • Apply compliance knowledge during renewals, implementations, and plan changes.
  • Identify situations that may require additional compliance review and engage appropriate internal or external resources.
  • Stay informed regarding carrier updates, industry trends, and market developments that may impact clients.

Operational Excellence

  • Maintain accurate client records, documentation, and activity tracking within agency management systems.
  • Follow established workflows, service standards, and departmental processes.
  • Ensure accuracy and completeness of proposals, contracts, applications, and other client deliverables.
  • Identify opportunities to improve efficiency, consistency, and the overall client experience.

Qualifications

Education & Experience

  • Bachelor's degree preferred.
  • 3 years of employee benefits insurance experience.
  • Indiana Life & Health Insurance License required.
  • Experience supporting fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded benefit programs preferred.

Skills & Attributes

  • Strong knowledge of employee benefits products and funding arrangements.
  • Excellent organizational and project management skills.
  • Ability to manage multiple priorities and competing deadlines.
  • Strong communication and relationship-building abilities.
  • Demonstrated problem-solving skills and attention to detail.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office Suite and agency management systems.
  • Accountable mindset with a proactive approach to client service and continuous improvement.

What Sets This Role Apart

The Account Manager serves as the operational leader of the client’s experience. This role owns execution, drives timelines, manages carrier relationships, and ensures every aspect of the renewal and service process is delivered with professionalism, accuracy, and consistency. Successful Account Managers combine technical expertise, strong communication skills, and a commitment to delivering exceptional client outcomes.

Salary.com Estimation for Account Manager, Employee Benefits in Indianapolis, IN
$112,958 to $142,290
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Account Manager, Employee Benefits?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Account Manager, Employee Benefits career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$117,681 - $153,066
Income Estimation: 
$167,784 - $219,716
Income Estimation: 
$104,545 - $161,038
Income Estimation: 
$130,351 - $192,268
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Gregory & Appel

  • Gregory & Appel Indianapolis, IN
  • Job Type Full-time Description At Gregory & Appel, we believe our colleagues are our greatest differentiator—and the experience people have joining our org... more
  • 5 Days Ago

  • Gregory & Appel Miami, FL
  • Description This is a growth platform for a high-potential Insurance Advisor who understands complex risk, navigates executive conversations with confidenc... more
  • 6 Days Ago

  • Gregory & Appel Indianapolis, IN
  • Job Type Full-time Description The Claims Advocate (CA) at Gregory & Appel works closely with our clients, insurance company representatives, producers, an... more
  • 15 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Account Manager, Employee Benefits jobs in the Indianapolis, IN area that may be a better fit.

  • Shepherd Insurance LLC Carmel, IN
  • Description PURPOSE: This is an ideal opportunity to work at a growing organization with a strong family culture. Shepherd Insurance is a privately-owned i... more
  • 7 Days Ago

  • Risk Placement Services, Inc. Indianapolis, IN
  • Introduction At RPS, we don’t just embrace bold ideas, we make them happen. We’re a team of entrepreneurs, big-picture thinkers, and passionate experts who... more
  • 7 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!