Demo

Claims Manager - Casualty

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.
Merrill, WI Full Time
POSTED ON 11/29/2025 CLOSED ON 2/10/2026

What are the responsibilities and job description for the Claims Manager - Casualty position at Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.?

What You'll Be Doing

Manage and provide strategic leadership to a claims team in accordance with company claim policies, practices, and procedures within delegated authority levels. This includes direct oversight and development of a specialized team of claims professionals handling General Liability, Professional Liability, Employment Practices Liability, and Directors, Officers and Trustees claims within our Casualty Large Loss group. Drive performance and claim outcomes by guiding claims management practices that align with operational goals and broader business objectives. Proactively identify and assess areas of potential business risk, and resolve complex complaints and disputes related to claim resolution. Oversee the operational budget and ensure effective expense control. Lead staffing strategies, including hiring, retention, and productivity management across the line of business. Supervisor responsibilities include workforce planning, training and development, and performance management to build a high performing, engaged team.

On Any Given Day, You'll

  • Manage the claim activity and workflow for multiple claims units to maintain the highest professional customer service and technical standards and to ensure work is produced in a timely fashion and that all deadlines are met.
  • Oversee the timely settlement of claims and acceptable closing ratios for the line of business.
  • Mediate complaints and disputes regarding claim resolution.
  • Develop, recommend, and manage the operating budget for the claims units in meeting the overall goals and objectives of the Claims Department.
  • Ensure each unit is meeting the expectations as defined through the unit's best practice guidelines and in compliance with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements.
  • Provide oversight on expense control in accordance with the unit's policies, practices, and procedures.
  • Manage and keep current on all claims processes, procedures, and changes in accordance with company guidelines.
  • Maintain override capability, authorize settlements up to designated authority limits, and submit recommendations to designated officials for those claims in excess of authority level.
  • Oversee claims staffing models, hiring and retention, and productivity numbers to ensure they are in compliance with company standards.
  • Identify areas of potential business risk and communicate these to the VP - Claims including, but not limited to, the following:
  • Claims with amounts in excess of authority.
  • Punitive damage claims or alleged punitive damage claims.
  • Errors and omissions claims.
  • Written customer complaints and any oral complaint not resolved or which you do not feel confident in handling.
  • All complaints filed with state insurance departments.
  • Claims involving bad faith or threats of bad faith or where you feel there is a potential claim for bad faith.
  • Directors, officers and trustees liability claims (Casualty, Subrogation.).
  • Extra contractual claims or claims for damages that reach or exceed limits of liability.
  • Denial of defense of our insureds.
  • Present claims committee transactions for approval or reporting as needed.
  • Travel as required for mediations, seminars, settlement conferences, etc.
  • Supervisor/manager responsibilities may include all of the following:

Staffing needs, to include interviewing and onboarding for new employees.

Training and development, as well as coaching and motivation, for staff.

Performance management, goal setting, employee engagement, and salary administration.

Work force management to include: unit equipment, software, and space needs, approving time off and overtime usage, and budget recommendations.

Here's What We Expect

  • A minimum of five to seven years of commercial lines claims experience and a minimum of two years of supervisory experience or equivalent is required.

Education

  • A four-year college degree or the equivalent in related insurance experience is required.
  • Completion of CPCU, AIM, and/or SCLA designations is preferred.

Necessary Knowledge And Abilities

  • Ability to manage effectively.
  • Leadership skills.
  • Strong customer service focus.
  • Strong strategic thinking skills.
  • Strong critical thinking skills.
  • Strong knowledge of multijurisdictional legal principles.
  • Knowledge of Microsoft Office tools.
  • Ability to understand and utilize business reports and other data analysis tools.
  • Ability to adapt to changing environments.
  • Collaboration and partnering skills.
  • Strong problem-solving skills.
  • Strong systemic-thinking skills.
  • Strong team-building skills.
  • Ability to elicit needed knowledge.

Church Mutual is an equal opportunity employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, veteran or disability status.

Exact compensation will vary based on consideration of a variety of factors including education, skills, experience, and location.

Salary.com Estimation for Claims Manager - Casualty in Merrill, WI
$95,760 to $121,295
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Claims Manager - Casualty?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Claims Manager - Casualty career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$133,026 - $172,136
Income Estimation: 
$173,898 - $215,349
Income Estimation: 
$175,869 - $224,608
Income Estimation: 
$226,328 - $346,983
Income Estimation: 
$181,348 - $253,947
Income Estimation: 
$123,613 - $165,638
Income Estimation: 
$142,348 - $187,535
Income Estimation: 
$164,116 - $229,853
Income Estimation: 
$162,278 - $218,065
Income Estimation: 
$63,693 - $82,116
Income Estimation: 
$78,860 - $101,439
Income Estimation: 
$73,591 - $100,276
Income Estimation: 
$92,577 - $120,619
This job has expired.
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

  • Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. Wausau, WI
  • The ideal candidate would live in the Northern part of WI which would include, Eau Claire, Green Bay, or Wausau. What You'll Be Doing Prospect and sell new... more
  • 14 Days Ago

  • Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. Merrill, WI
  • What You'll Do The Assistant Vice President of IT & Chief Technology Officer (CTO) is a senior IT executive role responsible for enterprise application dev... more
  • 16 Days Ago

  • Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. Madison, WI
  • This position can be located in Merrill, Madison, or Milwaukee, WI working on a hybrid basis with in office days Tuesday-Thursday. What You'll Be Doing Man... more
  • 2 Days Ago

  • Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. Milwaukee, WI
  • What You'll Be Doing In accordance with application of state and federal laws and company best practices, handle low to moderate value claims within an ass... more
  • 5 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Claims Manager - Casualty jobs in the Merrill, WI area that may be a better fit.

  • Sentry Stevens, WI
  • Sentry is seeking an analytical and results driven individual to expand our actuarial capabilities in Claims. This position will be responsible for develop... more
  • 26 Days Ago

  • Jewelers Mutual Group Neenah, WI
  • Summary Leadership role within the Claim Team focused upon coaching, training, development, and performance management of assigned claim team members. Owne... more
  • 10 Days Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!