Demo

Manager - Total Rewards

Acuity Insurance
Sheboygan, WI Full Time
POSTED ON 4/6/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 5/21/2026
Acuity is seeking a Manager – Total Rewards to oversee the management and coordination of the benefits and compensation functions, including employee benefit programs, compensation practices, leave administration, related compliance, and vendor management. This role is responsible for developing, executing, and monitoring a comprehensive total rewards strategy in coordination with leadership, while also partnering as needed with Employee Success, Talent Acquisition, and Payroll teams, and performing other duties as requested.

Internal Application Deadline: March 5, 2026

ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS:

  • Direct efforts and contribute to the development and implementation of a long-term total rewards strategy.
  • Manage total rewards vendor and consultant relationships, including the administration and selection of vendors through requests for proposals.
  • Manage 401(k) plan including but not limited to, establishing internal controls, coordinating outside independent audits, plan changes, and company-wide communication.
  • In coordination with HR leadership, enterprise leadership, and HR analysis peers, direct and facilitate processes associated with compensation planning, job pricing, and merit processes.
  • Contribute to the design, implementation and administration of career development and employee retention frameworks as it pertains to total rewards and pay for performance.
  • Oversee training and development of team, including total rewards best practices, and administration of policies and procedures.
  • In partnership with Employee Success, Legal and HR leadership, facilitate compensation and benefit aspects of separations, including but not limited to COBRA administration.
  • Partner with Learning & Development, Internal Communications, and management to develop and deliver training and educational programs for the employee population.
  • Maintain knowledge of industry trends and employment legislation to ensure organizational compliance and marketplace competitiveness. Communicate policies and procedures changes, partnering with Legal, other HR functions, and other teams.
  • Advise management on organizational policies and procedures, and federal and state regulations to ensure legal compliance pertaining to benefit, compensation and leave matters.
  • Coordinate and propose updates to leave and disability programs to remain competitive and compliant.
  • Assist in the assembly of the annual department budget.
  • Participate on committees and special projects and seek additional responsibilities.
  • Adhere to company policies and practices and comply with all state and federal regulations in all aspects of human resources management.
  • Maintain professional approach with confidentiality. Assure protection and privacy of health information as attained through written, electronic or oral disclosures.
  • Periodic review of and suggested enhancements for continued procedural efficiencies.
  • Regular and predictable attendance.
  • Performs other duties as assigned.


EDUCATION:

Bachelor's degree. Certified Employee Benefits Specialist (CEBS), Certified Compensation Professional (CCP), Qualified 401(k) Administrator (QKA), Certified Plan Sponsor Specialist (CPSP), SHRM-Certified Professional (SHRM-CP), Professional in Human Resources (PHR), or similar designation(s) preferred.

EXPERIENCE:

Six (6) or more years of Human Resources experience with demonstrated leadership in the Human Resources field. Previous management experience within total rewards strongly preferred.

OTHER QUALIFICATIONS:

  • Effective verbal and written communication skills, including demonstrated ability to brief executive audiences.
  • Ability to effectively guide others to desired outcomes.
  • Excellent interpersonal skills.
  • Advanced judgment and decision-making abilities.
  • Sound project management skills.
  • Strategic thinking skills, connecting day-to-day work to broader objectives.
  • Proactive organizational skills.
  • Ability to work independently, on a team, and in partnership with leaders within and across departments.
  • Willingness to take initiative.
  • Capacity for meeting deadlines while working under pressure.
  • Regard confidentiality with the highest integrity.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Word and Excel, along with HR information systems such as UKG Pro, benefits administration systems, and compensation analysis and planning systems.


*Acuity does not sponsor applicants for U.S. work authorization.*

This job is classified as exempt.

For this role, Acuity offers a comprehensive benefits package, including a generous 401(k) contribution, medical, dental, vision, life and disability insurance, paid time off, an Employee Assistance Program, and more. A full description of benefits and eligibility will be provided to candidates during the hiring process.

We are an Equal Employment Opportunity employer. Applicants and employees are considered for positions and are evaluated without regard to mental or physical disability, race, color, religion, gender, national origin, age, genetic information, military or veteran status, sexual orientation, marital status or any other protected Federal, State/Province or Local status unrelated to the performance of the work involved.

If you have a disability and require reasonable accommodations to apply or during the interview process, please contact our Talent Acquisition team at careers@acuity.com. Acuity is dedicated to offering reasonable accommodations during our recruitment process for qualified individuals.

Salary.com Estimation for Manager - Total Rewards in Sheboygan, WI
$154,063 to $191,097
If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at Acuity Insurance

  • Acuity Insurance Sheboygan, WI
  • Acuity is seeking a Custodian – Third Shift to maintain a high level of custodial detail for Acuity’s executive space, including private and open offices, ... more
  • 8 Days Ago

  • Acuity Insurance ID, ID
  • Acuity is seeking a Territory Director to manage the profitability and production of Acuity products in an assigned geographic area or territory; to profes... more
  • 10 Days Ago

  • Acuity Insurance Sheboygan, WI
  • Acuity is seeking a Technical Support Analyst Intern to install PC systems and peripherals. This role will load and verify operation of software such as op... more
  • 11 Days Ago

  • Acuity Insurance Sheboygan, WI
  • Acuity is seeking a General Manager - Marketing & Communication to oversee communications directed toward employees, agents, and customers, ensuring brand ... more
  • 11 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Manager - Total Rewards jobs in the Sheboygan, WI area that may be a better fit.

  • Voith Group Appleton, WI
  • About The Voith Group The Voith Group is a global technology company. With its broad portfolio of systems, products, services and digital applications, Voi... more
  • 3 Days Ago

  • Acuity Insurance and Careers Sheboygan, WI
  • Acuity is seeking a Manager – Total Rewards to oversee the management and coordination of the benefits and compensation functions, including employee benef... more
  • 1 Month Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!