Demo

Supervisor, Insurance - Sales

AAA Western and Central New York
Williamsville, NY Full Time
POSTED ON 10/21/2026
AVAILABLE BEFORE 11/19/2026
Compensation

  • Starting Pay Rate: $68,910.35 - $81,071.00 Incentive Opportunity

Benefits

Associates are eligible for a wide selection of benefits (dependent upon position) including:

  • Medical Insurance
  • Health Spending Account (HSA) with company match
  • Paid Time Off
  • Pre-Tax & Roth 401(k) plan with company match
  • Flexible Scheduling & Hybrid Work Opportunity
  • Dental and Vision Insurance
  • Life and AD&D Insurance
  • Tuition reimbursement & company-paid training programs
  • FREE AAA membership & travel / product discounts
  • Company Paid Short-term & Long-term disability
  • Paid Volunteer Time Off
  • Flexible Spending Accounts
  • Tuition reimbursement & company-paid training programs

Job Responsibilities

50% Performance Management: Responsible for driving execution to achieve department KPIs & overall growth of insurance business line. Collaborate with Insurance Leadership & Trainer(s) to deliver training focused on improving KPIs by targeting key gap and/or focus areas. Regularly provide advisors with targeted feedback on scorecard/KPI performance to ensure consistent focus on deliverables and that monthly/quarterly/annual goals are reached or exceeded.

20% Customer Experience: Understand insurance products and carriers to provide outstanding customer experiences. Identify opportunities to improve processes and systems that can enhance the ease of doing business with AAA. Be the subject matter expert for carrier products and underwriting guidelines and assist associates with questions. Liaison with the insurance carrier(s) to ensure timely and accurate underwriting and drive department quality to achieve department standard targets. Implement strategic actions that drive strong Ease of Use and Likely to renew survey scores.

15% Associate Development: Manage with the intent to motivate, train, and develop. Deliver timely, constructive feedback regarding progress of work & performance and provide team members with mentoring and resources to develop the skills necessary to advance their performance and careers. Create supportive culture that provides opportunities for all interested associates.

15% Leadership: Identify, recruit, & retain top performing employees and manage non-performing employees in accordance with company policy. Conduct timely and effective mid-year and annual reviews. Consistently complete daily responsibilities of associate coaching, team/individual communication, assisting associates with system or technical questions, documenting, and processing of customer/associate requests and work.

Job Specific Requirements

  • Responsible to obtain and maintain the required license or certification in an active status
  • Able to display expert-level knowledge of carrier offerings, processes, and requirements
  • Ability to work evenings, weekends, & events as required by business need/Leadership directive
  • Working knowledge of computer software and ability to effectively navigate multiple systems
  • Ability to operate independently and display expert-level of proficiency in minimization of errors & problem solving
  • Must be able to resolve problems and work under pressure to diffuse member concerns
  • Work under pressure during periods of high volume
  • Ability to multitask in various areas of insurance sales and service

Physical Requirements

  • Ability to perform routine office tasks that includes operating a computer for long periods of time, sitting, filing and communicating on the phone
  • Ability to perform all physical functions consistent with travel including sitting in airplanes and driving for long periods of time
  • Must be able to lift, carry, push, pull a maximum of 30 lbs

This position does not offer visa sponsorship now or in the future.

Salary : $68,910 - $81,071

If your compensation planning software is too rigid to deploy winning incentive strategies, it’s time to find an adaptable solution. Compensation Planning
Enhance your organization's compensation strategy with salary data sets that HR and team managers can use to pay your staff right. Surveys & Data Sets

What is the career path for a Supervisor, Insurance - Sales?

Sign up to receive alerts about other jobs on the Supervisor, Insurance - Sales career path by checking the boxes next to the positions that interest you.
Income Estimation: 
$68,180 - $90,382
Income Estimation: 
$139,000 - $187,744
Income Estimation: 
$68,180 - $90,382
Income Estimation: 
$139,000 - $187,744
Employees: Get a Salary Increase
View Core, Job Family, and Industry Job Skills and Competency Data for more than 15,000 Job Titles Skills Library

Job openings at AAA Western and Central New York

  • AAA Western and Central New York Penfield, NY
  • Compensation Starting Pay Rate: $18 - 20.10/hr Benefits Associates are eligible for a wide selection of benefits (dependent upon position) including: Medic... more
  • 12 Days Ago


Not the job you're looking for? Here are some other Supervisor, Insurance - Sales jobs in the Williamsville, NY area that may be a better fit.

  • Supervisor Lansing, MI
  • Accelerator Research & Development Supervisor Who we are… We are a team of scientists, engineers, technicians, and innovators dedicated to changing the wor... more
  • 1 Month Ago

  • Alfa Insurance Sales & HO Alabaster, AL
  • Job Overview Alfa Insurance is seeking ambitious individuals to join our team. This position offers the opportunity to build and manage your agency while r... more
  • 1 Month Ago

AI Assistant is available now!

Feel free to start your new journey!